From ABC7 New York · · 3m
Seven women linked to Philadelphia house investigation
Police connect multiple missing women to a home in Olney where over a million disturbing images were recovered.
In brief
Police connect multiple missing women to a home in Olney where over a million disturbing images were recovered. Seven women have been linked to an ongoing investigation centered on a Philadelphia home, with evidence suggesting foul play, but no bodies have been found and charges remain limited. Originally reported by…
Seven women linked to Olney house
Police have connected seven women to an investigation centered on a home in Philadelphia's Olney neighborhood, with five reported missing. Most appear in disturbing digital images recovered from the property.
Investigation began with June arrest
Eugene Horsch, 44, was arrested on Independence Mall in June 2026 after a federal park ranger spotted a suspicious vehicle. Police recovered guns, narcotics, and fake law enforcement credentials.
Blair Tonzelli, first woman named
Blair Tonzelli, 35, went missing in 2023. When Horsch was arrested, he was with a woman carrying an ID with Tonzelli's name. The woman said Horsch gave her the identification.
Amy McHale, last seen in 2016
Amy McHale, 44, was last seen in 2016 at the West Chew Avenue house. She was previously married to Raymond Horsch, Eugene's late father, who became central to the investigation.
Gabrielle Amarando vanished in 2012
Gabrielle Amarando, 22, disappeared in 2012. In August 2026, police found photos and videos showing her alive and then appearing dead. Her childhood friend remembered her as a wonderful soul.
“She was a wonderful soul. She really was.”
Maribel Fresses seen in videos
Maribel Fresses, 27, disappeared in 2018. Police found photos and videos showing her alive and then appearing dead. The medical examiner believes the images show her deceased.
Nicole Fusaro, alleged strangulation
Nicole Fusaro, 27, disappeared in 2018. Police described a video allegedly showing Raymond Horsch strangling a woman with a zip tie, believed to be Fusaro. Her cousin said she deserved better.
“Nicole was a beautiful, kindhearted woman who deserved so much better.”
Two more women unidentified
A 25-year-old woman appears injured and unconscious in recovered images. Police know her identity but her family requested anonymity. Another woman remains unidentified as a Jane Doe.
Over one million images recovered
Police recovered more than one million digital images from the home showing women injured, unconscious, and possibly lifeless. The FBI increased agents assigned to authenticate the massive collection.
No bodies found, charges limited
Despite extensive evidence, no bodies have been recovered. None of the women have been declared dead, and no charges related to the disappearances have been filed. Former FBI agent says lack of bodies makes the case challenging.
“Because there's no easy source of DNA to match to any potential forensic evidence.”
Chemicals and urns discovered
Police removed over 20 containers of unknown substance from a basement laboratory and pipes from the home, sent to federal testing in Chicago. Five urns with cremated remains were found, including one believed to contain Raymond Horsch's ashes.
Horsch indicted on weapons charges
Eugene Horsch was indicted in July 2026 for being a convicted felon in possession of firearms, including one with an obliterated serial number, and for possessing fake DEA and FBI credentials.
Police seek witnesses and information
Police executed nearly 100 search warrants on the property and continue investigating. They're asking anyone who visited the house or has information about activity there to contact the Philadelphia Police tip line.
The takeaway
Seven women have been linked to an ongoing investigation centered on a Philadelphia home, with evidence suggesting foul play, but no bodies have been found and charges remain limited.
