The Bermuda Triangle theory explained

A popular social media meme claims Brighton, Bournemouth and Brentford form a triangle where the Big Six lose points. Recent wins like Brentford's 3-0 over Chelsea and Brighton's 3-0 over Arsenal have fuelled the narrative.

Brighton's record is genuinely exceptional

Since the start of the 2024-25 season, Brighton have taken 42 points from 26 games against the Big Six, averaging 1.62 points per match. This is one of the best records any non-Big-Six club has produced in the Premier League era.

Bournemouth performs well but not spectacularly

Bournemouth have collected 35 points from 26 matches against the Big Six, averaging 1.35 points per game. They provide strong support to the theory but fall short of Brighton's exceptional standard.

Brentford's record doesn't match the hype

Brentford have taken only 22 points from 26 matches against the Big Six, averaging 0.85 points per game. Newcastle, Nottingham Forest and Aston Villa have all outperformed them against elite opposition over the same period.

Why the meme stuck despite mixed data

Upsets against richer clubs are more memorable because they fit a familiar story of well-run underdogs outperforming bigger spenders. Brentford's eye-catching wins, like their 3-0 rout of Spurs, help cement the reputation even if the overall numbers don't support it.

One standout club, not a triangle

The evidence points less to a three-club phenomenon and more to Brighton sitting firmly at the centre. Bournemouth provides strong support, while Brentford supplies memorable moments that keep the theory alive.

“If there is a Premier League Bermuda Triangle, Brighton sit firmly at its centre.”