Cover art for Best Cast-Iron Skillets After Years of Testing

Best Cast-Iron Skillets After Years of Testing

Lancaster and Victoria cast-iron skillets top Bon Appétit's side-by-side testing for nonstick performance and durability.

By ·

Jun 16, 2021

16 cards · 2m · tap to begin

From · · · 2m

Best Cast-Iron Skillets After Years of Testing

Lancaster and Victoria cast-iron skillets top Bon Appétit's side-by-side testing for nonstick performance and durability.

In brief

Lancaster and Victoria cast-iron skillets top Bon Appétit's side-by-side testing for nonstick performance and durability. Lancaster No. 8 Skillet and Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet win Bon Appétit's testing for best nonstick cast-iron skillet performance and longevity. Originally reported by Bon Appétit.

Why cast-iron skillets matter

Cast-iron pans improve with use, becoming more nonstick over time through oil polymerization.

The two main cast-iron fanbases

Some loyal to affordable USA-made Lodge, others to vintage Griswold or Wagner pans restored with DIY electrolysis.

Our testing goal

Our testing goal

Provide recommendations based on side-by-side testing and staff input, not changing loyalists' minds.

Top pick: Lancaster No. 8 Skillet

Lancaster No. 8 Skillet is the lightest cast-iron pan tested, heats quickly, and has a smooth cooking surface.

Lancaster's pros and cons

Pros: lightweight, smooth cooking surface, heats quickly, two pour spouts. Cons: pricey, preseasoning could be more robust.

Lancaster's seasoning performance

Some of the best cast iron skillets

Factory seasoning is smooth but not as robust as Lodge or Victoria pans; stains develop as seasoning matures.

Lancaster's long-term care

Stains fade with continued use; seasoning can be restored by cooking with the pan without additional maintenance.

Top pick: Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet

Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet offers affordable pricing with good nonstick performance and a comfortable handle design.

Victoria's pros and cons

Pros: affordable, two pour spouts, helper handle, comes preseasoned. Cons: heavier than Lancaster.

Victoria's factory seasoning

Victoria pans have a slicker factory seasoning than Lodge, making eggs and potatoes easier to fry without oil.

How we tested cast-iron pans

Staff tested pans for maneuverability, nonstick performance, heat distribution, and seasoning durability.

Why cast-iron is better than nonstick

Cast-iron pans are durable, retain heat well, and sear food without degrading over time unlike modern nonstick coatings.

Other good cast-iron skillets

Stargazer, Yeti, Lodge, Smithey, and Field Company skillets offer quality but vary in weight and seasoning durability.

Cast-iron skillets we don't recommend

Camp Chef, Valor, Finex, KitchenAid, Barebones, Victoria Signature Series, Cuisinel, Backcountry, Müeller, and Utopia Kitchen skillets have flaws in design or performance.

How to care for cast-iron skillets

Wipe with damp cloth, dry thoroughly, apply light oil after cooking to prevent rust and maintain seasoning.

Long-term cast-iron care

Rust spots can be fixed with salt scrub or vinegar soak; seasoning improves with continued use.

The big picture

Lancaster No. 8 Skillet and Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet win Bon Appétit's testing for best nonstick cast-iron skillet performance and longevity.

Read the original on Bon Appétit

Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.

How we make summaries

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on cast-iron skillet and related topics.