CBR
Cover art for 10 Anime With Major Plot Holes That Ruined Their Potential

10 Anime With Major Plot Holes That Ruined Their Potential

10 anime series that would have been masterpieces if not for glaring plot holes.

By ·

Nov 20, 2026

15 cards · 2m · tap to begin

From · · · 2m

10 Anime With Major Plot Holes That Ruined Their Potential

10 anime series that would have been masterpieces if not for glaring plot holes.

In brief

10 anime series that would have been masterpieces if not for glaring plot holes. These anime nearly achieved perfection but were undermined by inconsistent rules, sudden reveals, and unexplained logic. Originally reported by CBR.

Neon Genesis Evangelion's Human Instrumentality Project

Neon Genesis Evangelion's Human Instrumentality Project

The Human Instrumentality Project merges humanity into one being but lacks clear rules for Angels and Shinji's decisions.

“Why does merging all of humanity into one being solve anything? How exactly do the Angels fit into the process?”

Shu's Powers Collapse Under Contradictions

Shu's Void powers shift unpredictably, contradicting early rules and undermining the series' emotional core.

“Shu can wield multiple Voids at once, and then, he suddenly can't.”

Light's Sudden Recklessness in Death Note

Light's pride leads to amateur mistakes, undermining the perfect mind game established in the series.

“Light's pride puffs up so much that he leaves behind evidence and makes stupid gambles.”

NerveGear Logic Undermines Sword Art Online

The NerveGear premise assumes removing the headset kills the user, but never explains how or why.

“If the NerveGear only fries the brain when someone dies in-game, why can’t doctors or family members just safely remove the headset while players are alive?”

Geass Powers Break Their Own Rules

Lelouch's Geass ability shifts rules inconsistently, including accidental commands and evolving conditions.

“Lelouch even 'accidentally' commands Euphemia to commit mass murder, despite the anime never establishing that stray words could trigger Geass without intent.”

Alien Twist in Darling in the Franxx

The sudden introduction of aliens as pawns in an intergalactic war derails the grounded conflict.

“The Klaxosaurs were set up as mysterious but grounded threats, and the reveal that they were just pawns in an intergalactic war against the alien race, VIRM, pulled the rug out from under everything.”

Killer Reveal in Erased

The killer reveal lacks proper foreshadowing, making the final battle feel unearned and disconnected.

“The anime does not provide the proper foreshadowing. It feels forced, like the story wanted to find a twist and pointed to the nearest authority figure.”

Shikon Jewel Creates Endless Contradictions

The Shikon Jewel's rules shift constantly, corrupting humans and purifying evil without consistent logic.

“Sometimes, the Jewel can corrupt ordinary humans, turning them into demons, but other times, it purifies evil.”

Tokyo Ghoul Forgot Its Own Rules

Characters ignore powers they once relied on, and battles shift rules without explanation.

“Kaneki himself goes against past motivations every week, creating the sense that the narrative is attempting to hit deadlines rather than unfold naturally.”

Diaries Never Stay Consistent in Future Diary

Diary updates shift unpredictably, and the system's true nature is revealed too late.

“The timing of diary updates also shifts depending on what the plot needs, undercutting suspense.”

The Human Instrumentality Project

Neon Genesis Evangelion's Human Instrumentality Project lacks clear rules for Angels and Shinji's decisions.

“Why does merging all of humanity into one being solve anything? How exactly do the Angels fit into the process?”

Shu's Powers Collapse Under Contradictions

Shu's Void powers shift unpredictably, contradicting early rules and undermining the series' emotional core.

“Shu can wield multiple Voids at once, and then, he suddenly can't.”

Light's Sudden Recklessness in Death Note

Light's pride leads to amateur mistakes, undermining the perfect mind game established in the series.

“Light's pride puffs up so much that he leaves behind evidence and makes stupid gambles.”

NerveGear Logic Undermines Sword Art Online

The NerveGear premise assumes removing the headset kills the user, but never explains how or why.

“If the NerveGear only fries the brain when someone dies in-game, why can’t doctors or family members just safely remove the headset while players are alive?”

Geass Powers Break Their Own Rules

Lelouch's Geass ability shifts rules inconsistently, including accidental commands and evolving conditions.

“Lelouch even 'accidentally' commands Euphemia to commit mass murder, despite the anime never establishing that stray words could trigger Geass without intent.”

The takeaway

These anime nearly achieved perfection but were undermined by inconsistent rules, sudden reveals, and unexplained logic.

Read the original on CBR

Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.

How we make summaries

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on neon genesis evangelion and related topics.