From CBS Sports · · 2m
J.J. McCarthy's Vikings Tenure Ends
Vikings trade J.J. McCarthy after 10 starts as QB experiment unravels.
In brief
Vikings trade J.J. McCarthy after 10 starts as QB experiment unravels. Vikings traded J.J. McCarthy after 10 NFL starts as his rookie season ended due to injury and poor performance. Originally reported by CBS Sports.
Vikings trade J.J. McCarthy
Vikings traded J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick after his 10th NFL start.
McCarthy's college success
McCarthy led Michigan to a national championship with 72.3% completion rate, 22 touchdowns and four interceptions.
NFL readiness concerns
McCarthy struggled with accuracy and pocket pressure during his rookie season, completing only 332 passes in 15 games.
Injury impacts season
McCarthy suffered a torn meniscus during preseason, missing all of 2024 and forcing Sam Darnold to take over.
Vikings' quarterback decision
Vikings named Kyler Murray the starter before the season began after McCarthy's poor performance.
McCarthy's performance metrics
McCarthy ranked 34th in EPA per dropback and last in interceptions among first-round quarterbacks since 2016.
McCarthy's development challenges
McCarthy struggled with timing and route anticipation, described as 'unpredictable' by Vikings players.
Vikings' organizational shift
Vikings fired general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah after a 9-8 season and McCarthy's poor performance.
McCarthy's future with Giants
McCarthy will join the Giants to continue his NFL career after being traded by the Vikings.
QB comparison to past picks
Trey Lance and Sam Darnold both had shorter tenures than McCarthy after being drafted in the first round.
McCarthy's career trajectory
McCarthy's NFL career continues with the Giants after his Vikings tenure ended in 2025.
Vikings' organizational consequences
Vikings fired general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah after a 9-8 season and McCarthy's poor performance.
McCarthy's next challenge
McCarthy must prove he can handle the pressure of being a starting quarterback with the Giants.
Vikings' decision impact
Vikings traded McCarthy after 10 starts as their experiment with a young quarterback unraveled.
Here's the gist
Vikings traded J.J. McCarthy after 10 NFL starts as his rookie season ended due to injury and poor performance.
