From Dailymail · · 4m
Pension tax trap threatens millions under Labour
State pension rises push pensioners into income tax for first time, but government protection plan may help only one in 16.
In brief
State pension rises push pensioners into income tax for first time, but government protection plan may help only one in 16. The triple lock guarantee on state pensions is colliding with frozen tax thresholds, creating a stealth tax that will hit most pensioners despite Labour's pledge to protect them. Originally…
Millions face pension tax trap
Due to the triple lock, the state pension will rise to just over thirteen thousand pounds in April, crossing the income tax threshold of twelve thousand five hundred seventy pounds for the first time.
Only one in 16 pensioners protected
Analysis by Lane Clark and Peacock found that fewer than one in five of the five point five million people on the new state pension would be helped by the government's plans. None of the seven point seven million on the old state pension would be helped.
Government pledges protection unclear
The Prime Minister's spokesman said the government would ensure anyone whose only income is the basic state pension will not pay income tax. But Downing Street could not explain how this would work or how many people it would help.
Burnham's campaign promise fades
During the Makerfield by-election in June, Andy Burnham suggested he would address the freezing of the personal allowance dragging pensioners into tax. In office, he has reverted to a previous policy helping only those with no additional income.
“What I have heard on doorsteps is pensioners saying the freezing of the personal allowance has dragged more and more pensioners into tax.”
Proper fix costs over one billion
Raising the tax threshold for all pensioners would cost more than one billion pounds. Former pensions minister Sir Steve Webb said the government appears unwilling to spend that much, so will pursue a much more restricted and cheaper option.
“Fixing this properly by raising the tax threshold for pensioners would cost more than £1billion.”
Old pensioners miss out entirely
The old state pension is worth less than ten thousand pounds a year. Around six point six million recipients top this up with additional state pensions and private provision, but they risk missing out on government assistance because they are not solely reliant on the basic state pension.
Tax freeze created stealth tax
The freeze on tax thresholds was introduced by the Conservative government to help pay for the four hundred billion pound cost of dealing with COVID. It was then extended by former Chancellor Rachel Reeves until twenty thirty-one.
Conservatives had proposed solution
At the last election, the Conservatives unveiled plans for a triple lock plus policy, which would raise the tax threshold for pensioners. Labour has not adopted this approach.
Healey under budget pressure
Chancellor John Healey is under pressure to find big savings to reassure financial markets that Labour can be trusted with public finances. Details of pension protection will be announced at next month's Budget.
Markets demand spending cuts
Former Bank of England economist Andy Haldane warned that financial markets would continue to drive up the government's borrowing costs unless ministers show they are serious about curbing spending.
“The markets now suspect that this is a traditional tax-and-spend socialist government with better TikTok videos.”
Triple lock collision course
The triple lock guarantees the state pension rises by the highest of three measures: inflation, average earnings, or two point five percent. This guarantee is now colliding with the frozen tax threshold, creating an unintended tax trap.
Pensioners feel double squeeze
Pensioners report feeling that what they have gained through one policy is being taken away through another. The combination of rising pensions and frozen tax thresholds creates a sense of unfair treatment.
“What they have got through one way, they are saying now that it's being taken away in another.”
Biggest stealth tax in history
The ongoing freeze on tax thresholds has been described as the biggest stealth tax in history, dragging millions of people into paying higher rates. It now looks set to drag in millions more pensioners.
April deadline approaches
The state pension rise takes effect in April, giving the government just months to announce and implement its protection plan. The Budget announcement will be crucial for clarifying which pensioners will be helped.
Five point five million at risk
Five point five million people receive the new state pension introduced in twenty sixteen. Most of them will face income tax bills despite the government's pledge to protect pensioners.
Seven point seven million older pensioners
Seven point seven million people receive the old state pension, which is worth less than the new threshold. They are unlikely to receive any government protection under current plans.
Policy choice limits options
By restricting help to pensioners with no additional income, the government keeps costs down but excludes millions who have modest supplementary pensions or savings. This narrow approach leaves most pensioners exposed.
The headline
The triple lock guarantee on state pensions is colliding with frozen tax thresholds, creating a stealth tax that will hit most pensioners despite Labour's pledge to protect them.

