Is AppleCare actually worth paying for?

A cracked iPhone 17 screen costs $329 to fix, or $29 with coverage. Here's when the math works.

By ·

Sep 14, 2026

7 cards · 1m 40s · tap to begin

From · · · 1m 40s

Is AppleCare actually worth paying for?

A cracked iPhone 17 screen costs $329 to fix, or $29 with coverage. Here's when the math works.

In brief

A cracked iPhone 17 screen costs $329 to fix, or $29 with coverage. Here's when the math works. AppleCare pays for itself the moment you break one thing, so buy it if you're clumsy and skip it if you're not. Originally reported by Engadget.

The warranty gap

An iPhone showing the AppleCare & Warranty menu.

Every Apple device ships with a one-year warranty, but it only covers factory defects and hardware failures. Drop your phone and you're on your own.

“It won't cover accidental damage, like if you drop your iPhone and damage the display.”

$329 for a cracked screen

An iPhone with shattered back glass.

Shatter the display on an iPhone 17 and the out-of-warranty repair runs $329. That single number is the whole argument for buying coverage.

“If you crack the screen of your iPhone 17, brace yourself to spend $329 on a repair.”

Not the old flat fee

The AppleCare menu on an iPhone, with an Apple Watch next to it and a MacBook in the background.

AppleCare used to be one $199 payment for a set term. Now it's monthly plans, theft protection and bundles, covering everything from Vision Pro to AirPods.

What it actually costs

AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss runs $13.99 a month for an iPhone 17 Pro, $9.99 for a 17e, and just $1.99 for AirPods Pro. Theft coverage skips Macs and accessories.

Deductibles still apply

Repairs are unlimited, but you pay $29 for a screen, $99 for other phone damage and $149 to replace a stolen or lost device. Still far below list price.

“While they sting a bit, these deductibles are still nowhere near what a repair costs without coverage.”

One plan, three devices

One plan, three devices

AppleCare One covers three devices for $19.99 a month, plus $5.99 for each extra. It's live in the US, UK, France, Germany and Australia.

Or just save the money

Carriers and SquareTrade undercut Apple on some plans, and SquareTrade covers four phones for $19.99. If you've never broken a phone, bank the cash instead.

“Then you have the cash in case you need repairs, but can also put it toward a new device if nothing happens.”

The one thing

AppleCare pays for itself the moment you break one thing, so buy it if you're clumsy and skip it if you're not.

Read the original on Engadget

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on applecare and related topics.