From Financialexpress · Mithilesh Jha · · 2m
Taxpayer wins Rs 3.98 crore tax case after ITAT quashes notices
Gujarat taxpayer avoids Rs 4 crore tax additions after ITAT rules notices issued beyond legal deadline.
In brief
Gujarat taxpayer avoids Rs 4 crore tax additions after ITAT rules notices issued beyond legal deadline. Gujarat taxpayer Shantilal Ranchhodbhai Dhanani won Rs 3.98 crore in tax additions after Ahmedabad ITAT quashed reassessment notices issued beyond permissible time limits. Originally reported by Financialexpress.
Taxpayer wins Rs 3.98 crore tax case
Gujarat taxpayer Shantilal Ranchhodbhai Dhanani avoided nearly rs 4 crore in income tax additions after challenging reassessment notices issued beyond the permissible time limit.
ITAT quashes tax notices
Ahmedabad ITAT ruled reassessment notices issued beyond the surviving limitation period were invalid for two assessment years.
Tax additions challenged

Taxpayer faced rs 2.02 crore addition for 2015-16 and rs 1.96 crore addition for 2016-17 under section 69 of income tax act.
Time limit dispute
Department issued notices on june 30 2021 but had only one day of limitation period before taxpayer response.
Supreme Court ruling
Supreme Court held that time given to taxpayer to respond must be excluded from limitation period calculation.
Taxpayer response deadline
Taxpayer submitted response on june 14 2022 giving department until june 21 2022 to complete reassessment.
Department missed deadline
Department issued fresh notices on july 23 2022 and july 31 2022 after deadline expired.
ITAT quashes notices
Ahmedabad ITAT set aside notices issued on july 23 and july 31 2022 for both assessment years.
Gujarat High Court precedent
Gujarat High Court had previously ruled that notices beyond surviving limitation period are invalid.
Taxpayer advice
Taxpayers should preserve original notices and supporting documents to challenge department procedures.
What this means
Tax department must follow legal procedure and time limits when reopening assessments.
Legal basis
Section 148 of income tax act allows department to reopen assessments with proper procedure.
Taxpayer's legal argument
Taxpayer argued notices issued after limitation period expired and lacked proper cross-examination opportunity.
Supreme Court interpretation
Supreme Court clarified that time for taxpayer response must be excluded from limitation period calculation.
Taxpayer wins
Taxpayer avoided rs 3.98 crore tax additions by challenging notices issued beyond legal deadline.
The headline
Gujarat taxpayer Shantilal Ranchhodbhai Dhanani won Rs 3.98 crore in tax additions after Ahmedabad ITAT quashed reassessment notices issued beyond permissible time limits.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.




