Trump Wants to Ban Diesel Exports. It Won't Help.

A proposed ban on U.S. diesel exports would backfire, raising prices globally and cutting refinery output when the world needs more fuel.

12 cards · 3m · tap to begin

From · · · 3m

Trump Wants to Ban Diesel Exports. It Won't Help.

A proposed ban on U.S. diesel exports would backfire, raising prices globally and cutting refinery output when the world needs more fuel.

In brief

A proposed ban on U.S. diesel exports would backfire, raising prices globally and cutting refinery output when the world needs more fuel. Export bans on energy products don't lower prices; they shrink production and shift costs elsewhere, making the problem worse. Originally reported by Foreign Policy.

Diesel prices hit farmers and truckers hard

U.S. diesel now costs $6.52 a gallon, up from $3.69 a year ago. Gasoline averages $4.47. The spike is hammering truckers and farmers across the country.

“Gasoline in the United States now averages $4.47 a gallon, but more to the point, diesel is now $6.52 a gallon on average, up from $3.69 from one year ago.”

Trump proposes banning diesel exports

Trump is seen from the chest upward, slightly out of focus in the foreground and gesturing with both hand as he speaks. The other two men stand behind him, in f

Facing pressure on Capitol Hill, Trump's administration is pushing to ban U.S. diesel exports, hoping to keep more fuel domestic and lower prices.

Energy secretary warns ban won't work

Trump's own energy secretary said in New York that a diesel export ban would fail and lead to higher prices as refiners cut back output.

U.S. is now a major oil and fuel exporter

A decade ago, the U.S. couldn't export oil at all due to 1970s price controls. Today, the fracking revolution made it the world's largest oil and gas producer.

Exports make up 12 percent of refinery output

Exports make up 12 percent of refinery output

U.S. refineries export about 1.4 million barrels of diesel daily, roughly 12 percent of total output. Banning exports would force refiners to cut production.

Ban would shift costs, not solve them

A temporary price dip on the Gulf Coast would be offset by higher prices elsewhere in the U.S. and globally. Refiners would eventually throttle back production.

“The U.S. Gulf Coast would get a temporary pump price dip, at the cost of likely higher coastal prices [elsewhere] and eventually, higher prices for everyone as investment gets scared away.”

Refiners enjoy historically high profit margins

Refineries are running at full capacity with a large crack spread, the profit difference between crude and refined products. An export ban would kill this incentive to produce more.

U.S. oil type doesn't match refinery needs

The U.S. produces light, sweet crude, but its refineries are built to process heavy, sour oil. An export ban would force refiners into costly bidding wars or suboptimal operations.

Real problem is Iran war, not Ukraine

Trump's February war on Iran has partially closed two major energy chokepoints: the Strait of Hormuz and Bab el-Mandeb. This is the main driver of global fuel shortages.

World lacks refining capacity, not crude

Russia is hurting from sanctions, the Middle East is worse off, and China shut down exports. The global shortage is refining capacity, not oil supply.

“Russia is hurting, but the Middle East is worse, and China shut down. What the world is short of is refining capacity.”

Export ban echoes failed 1970s policy

Trump is mimicking Richard Nixon's 1970s approach: tariffs, price controls, and energy market interference. That era ended with worse shortages and higher prices.

Ban would make global crisis worse

An American diesel export ban won't help the Middle East or global refining shortages. It will only make the worldwide energy crisis worse by cutting U.S. production.

The short version

Export bans on energy products don't lower prices; they shrink production and shift costs elsewhere, making the problem worse.

Read the original on Foreign Policy

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on donald trump and related topics.