From Indiatimes · TOI World Desk · · 2m
Canadian couple wins legal battle to keep unauthorized deck
Canadian couple keeps wooden deck at BC resort after appeals court rejects demolition order.
In brief
Canadian couple keeps wooden deck at BC resort after appeals court rejects demolition order. Moira and Denis Holden kept their unauthorized wooden deck at Valley’s Edge Resort in British Columbia after a November 13 appeals ruling awarded $5,000 in damages instead of demolition. Originally reported by Indiatimes.
Unauthorized deck construction
A Canadian couple built a wooden deck beside their holiday cabin without written approval at Valley’s Edge Resort in British Columbia.
Resort manager's demand for removal
The resort manager wanted the deck demolished after the couple completed construction without obtaining required written permission.
November 13 appeals ruling
A November 13 appeals ruling let the deck stay with a $5,000 payment instead of demolition.
Legal dispute background
The dispute began when the couple approached the strata council in 2022 with deck plans that the council said they lacked authority to approve.
30-day deadline for action
Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. gave the couple 30 days to either dismantle the deck or submit a complete application for approval.
Hand-drawn submission rejected
The couple submitted a hand-drawn diagram but the company’s president rejected it as incomplete.
First court's decision
The judge found the company’s president had not clearly explained what information was missing from the application.
Deck's environmental fit
The court considered the deck's appearance and impact, finding it consistent with the cabin and resort environment.
No neighbor impact
The court found no evidence the deck prevented neighboring property owners from accessing or enjoying their lots.
Resort's precedent argument
The resort administrator argued allowing the structure to remain would set an undesirable precedent for other property owners.
Court's financial decision
The court ordered the couple to pay $5,000 in damages instead of demolishing the deck.
Original damages claim
Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. sought $20,000 in damages while the couple argued they spent only $1,800 building the deck.
Appeal decision
The British Columbia Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals, upholding the $5,000 damages award.
Costs order
The court ordered each side to pay the other’s costs for defending the appeal at Scale A.
Legal consequences
The ruling reinforces that property owners cannot disregard construction approval requirements even when demolition is unnecessary.
What it means
Moira and Denis Holden kept their unauthorized wooden deck at Valley’s Edge Resort in British Columbia after a November 13 appeals ruling awarded $5,000 in damages instead of demolition.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.




