From LA NACION · LA NACION · · 1m 40s
Argentina's top court orders education data released
The Supreme Court rejected the government's secrecy argument and ordered publication of school-by-school test results from 2016 and 2017.
In brief
The Supreme Court rejected the government's secrecy argument and ordered publication of school-by-school test results from 2016 and 2017. Argentina's Supreme Court ordered the government to publish school-by-school results from Aprender tests in Salta for 2016 and 2017, rejecting claims that disclosure would…
Court orders test results published

Argentina's Supreme Court ordered the government to release school-by-school results from Aprender and Enseñar evaluations for Salta province in 2016 and 2017.
Government argued against disclosure
The government claimed publishing data would create school rankings, stigmatise students and teachers, and damage the evaluation system by reducing honest responses.
Court rejected secrecy argument
The court said making information public serves equality of opportunity, not stigmatisation, and allows communities to demand policies to reverse poor results.
“make public the information requerida, por lo tanto, apunta a efectivizar la igualdad real de oportunidades, antes que a estigmatizar alumnos y docentes”
The case began seven years earlier
Rafael Aurelio Argañaraz Olivero, a Salta parent, filed the lawsuit in 2019 seeking school-by-school results. The government had offered only aggregated data by municipality.
Court rejected confidentiality claims
The court said the government failed to prove that statistical secrecy laws applied or that stigmatisation risk existed in each case, calling the refusal generic and conjectural.
Salta judges must now set limits
The lower court in Salta must now define how to release data without revealing information that could identify people who participated in the tests, especially minors.
The main idea
Argentina's Supreme Court ordered the government to publish school-by-school results from Aprender tests in Salta for 2016 and 2017, rejecting claims that disclosure would stigmatise schools and students.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.


/file/attachments/2984/2247959047_577083_591a2a1831abee0bad2c2e5688ac7b5f.jpg)
/file/dailymaverick/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Alibaba.jpg)