From Law & Crime · · 2m
Man Mailed Peanut Butter Card to Ex-Wife's Allergic Friend
Florida man blamed ex-wife for divorce and mailed peanut butter-filled card to her best friend with life-threatening allergy.
In brief
Florida man blamed ex-wife for divorce and mailed peanut butter-filled card to her best friend with life-threatening allergy. Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. mailed peanut butter-filled greeting card to ex-wife's best friend with severe peanut allergy, causing her to suffer hives and tingling for six hours. Originally…
Ex-wife's best friend
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. mailed peanut butter-filled greeting card to ex-wife's best friend with life-threatening allergy.
Peanut allergy reaction
She suffered hives on both arms and tingling that lasted six hours after opening the card.
Divorce blame
Cancellare blamed ex-wife for divorce and claimed she had a life-threatening peanut allergy.
Card delivery
She saw a blue envelope that appeared greasy when picking up mail in August 2025.
Peanut butter card
The card allegedly contained a brown substance she recognized as peanut butter.
Cancellare's history
Cancellare and the victim have known each other for 20 years and went to dinner regularly.
Allergy awareness
She could react to peanuts through touch, ingestion, or airborne toxins without immediate intervention.
Cancellare's arrest
Cancellare was arrested on Friday and taken to Broward County Jail after posting bond.
Divorce details
The divorce was contentious and Cancellare largely blamed the victim for the breakup.
Peanut allergy
She had a deathly allergy to peanut butter that could cause death without immediate intervention.
Cancellare's actions
Cancellare used his credit card to buy stamps from a Davie Post Office kiosk about a week before the package delivery.
Cancellare's face
The kiosk captured Cancellare's face in a photo that the victim immediately recognized.
Cancellare's charges
Cancellare is charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence.
Last contact
The victim last saw Cancellare about three years earlier during property division.
Cancellare's next court date
Cancellare's next court date is not listed after posting bond.
The essence
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. mailed peanut butter-filled greeting card to ex-wife's best friend with severe peanut allergy, causing her to suffer hives and tingling for six hours.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.
