Years of Old Spice, then a rash

For years, Old Spice Wilderness worked perfectly with its strong lavender scent and smooth application. Last April, it suddenly caused a burning, itchy rash under both arms.

The sweat problem in NYC

As a heavy sweater living in a walkable city, the author spends days traversing streets, packing into subway cars, and working in stuffy offices. Summer meant commuting in one shirt and changing immediately upon arrival.

Skeptical about natural deodorant

The author assumed natural deodorants don't irritate skin but aren't effective for heavy sweaters. He trusted the recommendation of Grooming Editor Sean Zucker and tried Salt & Stone.

Black Rose & Oud surprised him

Seeking a scent similar to his beloved Old Spice lavender, he chose Black Rose and Oud instead. The complex, cologne-level scent was stronger than expected and lasted throughout the day without overpowering his cologne.

“At first swipe, I'm kissed from the rose much like Seal, which settles nicely as the day goes on.”

Natural deodorant actually controls sweat

While deodorants mask odor rather than block sweat, Salt & Stone kept dampness at bay better than expected. Applied morning and after his nightly shower, it kept him fresh and mostly dry throughout summer.

“deodorants do not block sweat; they mask body odor”

Worth the $20 price tag

At $20, Salt & Stone costs more than Old Spice but delivers: rash-free, sweat-free, and great-smelling skin no matter how many subway stairs or stuffy offices. The investment opened his eyes to cologne and scent wardrobes.

“good shit ain't cheap, cheap shit ain't good”