From Music Business Worldwide · · 1m 30s
Majors Push Supreme Court to Block Copyright Ruling
Music publishers urge Supreme Court to prevent global copyright disruption from songwriter termination case.
In brief
Music publishers urge Supreme Court to prevent global copyright disruption from songwriter termination case. Music publishers argue a Supreme Court decision could disrupt global copyright deals by allowing songwriters to retain international rights after termination. Originally reported by Music Business Worldwide.
Majors and BMG urge Supreme Court
The music industry majors and BMG have told the US Supreme Court they should not let a Fifth Circuit decision disrupt copyright worldwide.
Fifth Circuit Ruling on Termination
A January 12 ruling held that termination under US law returns songwriters' rights globally, not just in the United States.
Publishers' Reply Brief
Publishers filed a reply brief arguing Vetter’s case could cause significant disruption to global music licensing deals.
Vetter's Opposition Argument
Vetter argued publishers could negotiate deals without international rights concerns and that the issue should be resolved through other appeals courts first.
Industry Negotiations Timeline
Publishers say the industry is actively negotiating deals running through 2072 with foreign rights representing a significant portion of license value.
Short-Term Licensing Impact
Licensing deals become more expensive and some may collapse if potential licensees fear foreign infringement litigation.
Medium-Term Consequences
Vetter’s position risks a pyrrhic victory as the industry faces prolonged legal uncertainty.
Long-Term Societal Impact
Creative works may not be produced due to prolonged legal uncertainty and disrupted licensing.
Case Background
The dispute concerns Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love), a song Vetter wrote with Donald Smith in 1962 and assigned to Windsong Music Publishers.
The main idea
Music publishers argue a Supreme Court decision could disrupt global copyright deals by allowing songwriters to retain international rights after termination.
