From New York Giants On SI · · 2m
Giants QB Debate Heats Up After McCarthy’s Record-Setting Comeback Bid
Giants QB Jameis Winston’s Week 6 loss to Saints sparks debate over his starting role after backup J.J. McCarthy’s record-breaking fourth-quarter performance.
In brief
Giants QB Jameis Winston’s Week 6 loss to Saints sparks debate over his starting role after backup J.J. McCarthy’s record-breaking fourth-quarter performance. Giants quarterback Jameis Winston lost his starting job after two costly interceptions in Week 6, but credited backup J.J. McCarthy for helping the team recover…
Giants QB Jameis Winston
New York Giants quarterback Jameis Winston entered Week 6 of the 2026 NFL season seemingly secure as Big Blue’s starting quarterback.
Winston’s Stats
The 32-year-old had thrown for 805 yards, six touchdowns, to only three interceptions since being named the team’s QB1 after incumbent Jaxson Dart’s season-ending knee injury in Week 2.
Game Outcome
New York lost 34-27 to New Orleans Saints at MetLife Stadium after two costly second-half interceptions.
Winston’s Postgame Regret
Winston said he left a lot of plays out there that he could have executed better.
First Half Safety
Winston played a relatively safe first-half by his standards before a third-quarter interception.
Third Quarter Turnover
Saints cornerback Martin Emerson, Jr. intercepted Winston while attempting to find Malik Nabers.
Field Goal After Turnover
Kicker Daniel Carlson made a 51-yard field goal to put Saints ahead 27-10.
Second Interception
Winston threw his second costly interception to Saints safety Julian Blackmon.
Fourth Quarter Score
New Orleans scored a touchdown to take a 34-10 lead after two plays.
Coach’s Decision
Coach John Harbaugh inserted backup J.J. McCarthy with 11 minutes remaining in the fourth quarter.
McCarthy’s Performance
McCarthy went 11-of-21 for 243 yards, one touchdown, and one interception in 11 minutes.
Record-Breaking Stats
McCarthy’s 243 passing yards were the most in an 11-minute span in NFL history.
Winston’s Credit
Winston credited McCarthy for helping New York get back on track after the change.
Winston’s Final Thoughts
Winston said he would focus on improving and getting better for the team’s next game.
The bottom line
Giants quarterback Jameis Winston lost his starting job after two costly interceptions in Week 6, but credited backup J.J. McCarthy for helping the team recover with a record-setting 243 passing yards in 11 minutes.
