From New York Jets On SI · · 2m
Will McDonald IV makes his case for a Jets extension
The pass rusher dominated in Week 1, but needs to prove he's more than a one-dimensional player to earn a new deal.
In brief
The pass rusher dominated in Week 1, but needs to prove he's more than a one-dimensional player to earn a new deal. McDonald's strong opener showed improvement against the run, but he needs consistent three-down play to secure a contract extension from the Jets. Originally reported by New York Jets On SI.
Jets dominate Titans in opener
New York crushed Tennessee 23-10 with a complete team effort. The pass rush led the way with three sacks and five QB hits on Cam Ward.
McDonald shines in Week 1
Will McDonald IV recorded a sack, five pressures, and four hurries against the Titans. He's now in the final year of his rookie contract.
18.5 sacks in two seasons
McDonald led the Jets with eight sacks in 2025 and has 18.5 total over the past two years. His strong start shows why New York should prioritize keeping him.
Run defense was the concern
McDonald struggled against the run last season with five missed tackles and a 19.2% miss percentage. He ranked 112th among edge rushers with a 41.6 run-defense grade.
Week 1 addressed the weakness
Pro Football Focus gave McDonald an 80.7 overall grade, ranking him 14th among edge rushers. His improved run defense was a key part of the Jets' dominant performance.
New defensive line pieces emerge
Kingsley Enagbare and second overall pick David Bailey both recorded sacks alongside McDonald. T'Vondre Sweat was an unsung hero in the win.
Bailey takes pressure off McDonald
McDonald posted a team-high 80.8 pass rush grade and benefited from having Bailey command attention. Other talented players should help him create even more pressure.
Consistency questions remain
Four of McDonald's eight sacks last season came in one Week 10 game against Cleveland. He wasn't a constant force throughout the year.
Competition from new additions
The Jets brought in several offseason acquisitions capable of challenging McDonald. He entered 2026 facing pressure to prove he deserves a long-term deal.
Three-down defender is the goal
If McDonald replicates his pass rush success and improves against the run, he'll be worthy of a sizable extension. Becoming reliable on all three downs is key.
One game won't decide everything
McDonald needed a strong statement to start the season, and he delivered. Continued intensity could make his extension a top priority for the organization.
The big picture
McDonald's strong opener showed improvement against the run, but he needs consistent three-down play to secure a contract extension from the Jets.
