Six homers, one long night for Gerrit Cole

The Mets hit six home runs in the Bronx and pushed the Yankees' clinch party back a day.

Sep 12, 2026

9 cards · 2m · tap to begin

From · · 2m

Six homers, one long night for Gerrit Cole

The Mets hit six home runs in the Bronx and pushed the Yankees' clinch party back a day.

In brief

The Mets hit six home runs in the Bronx and pushed the Yankees' clinch party back a day. Cole has given up seven homers in his last two starts, and that is the Yankees' real October question. Originally reported by New York Post.

A roadblock in the Bronx

A roadblock in the Bronx

The Yankees lost 12-2 to the Mets on Saturday, ending a four-game winning streak and stalling a season that had been rolling toward October.

The clinch has to wait

New York needed a win plus a Blue Jays loss to Baltimore to lock up a wild card. Now they wait until Sunday at the earliest.

Cole gets roughed up

New York New York Yankees pitcher Gerrit Cole (45) reacts on the mound during the fifth inning

His worst start since returning from Tommy John surgery. Three homers allowed, boos on the walk off in the fifth, and seven homers across his last two outings.

“He got roughed up. That's a hot team in here, swinging the bat well.”

Lindor sets the tone

New York Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor (12) grand slam home run during the eighth inning when the New York Yankees played the New York Mets Saturday, Septembe

The Mets shortstop jumped on Cole's third pitch of the game and drove it into the right field seats. He finished with two homers, including a grand slam.

“I did hear the fans. It's been an uphill fight all year.”

The homers kept coming

New York Mets left fielder Juan Soto (22) scores on his solo home run during the seventh inning

Luis Torrens added a two-run shot in the second. Carson Benge hit his 17th of the season in the third to make it 4-0, then singled home the run that ended Cole's day.

Six is the season high

It matched the most home runs the Yankees have allowed in any game this year, in front of a sold-out crowd that started chanting for the visitors.

“They're really passionate fans. We want to have a good day anywhere we go.”

Zac Thornton silenced them

New York Mets pitcher Tobias Myers (32) and catcher Luis Torrens (13) greet each other after the ninth inning of the game.

The rookie lefty retired the first nine Yankees and needed just 81 pitches for seven innings, giving up two runs to a lineup energized by Aaron Judge's return.

The double play that sealed it

Yankees left fielder Cody Bellinger (35) rounds the bases.

With two on in the seventh, Andy Green went to the mound. Thornton said he would get a double-play ball, then got Anthony Volpe to hit into one.

“He said he was gonna get a double-play ball.”

Too late, but still hot

The Mets are 22-13 since selling at the deadline and have won five of six. If that makes the crosstown path to October harder, they will take it.

“This is what we should have been doing since the beginning.”

The takeaway

Cole has given up seven homers in his last two starts, and that is the Yankees' real October question.

Read the original on New York Post

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on mlb and related topics.