From Newsweek · · 1m 50s
Immigration Judges Challenge Supreme Court on Free Speech
Immigration judges appeal to Supreme Court over First Amendment restrictions on public speech.
In brief
Immigration judges appeal to Supreme Court over First Amendment restrictions on public speech. Immigration judges seek Supreme Court review of a DOJ policy that bars them from speaking publicly about immigration, claiming it violates their First Amendment rights. Originally reported by Newsweek.
Immigration judges file First Amendment appeal

Immigration judges ask Supreme Court to review a DOJ policy restricting their public speech on immigration.
NAIJ petitions Supreme Court for review

The National Association of Immigration Judges filed a petition Tuesday to have the Supreme Court review an appeals court ruling that prevents them from challenging the policy directly in federal district court.
First Amendment injury claimed
Judges argue that forcing them to wait while the policy remains in place creates an immediate First Amendment injury by chilling speech before it even happens.
Knight Institute's legal stance
Ramya Krishnan, senior staff attorney for the Knight First Amendment Institute, says public employees should be able to challenge government speech restraints immediately.
Immigration judges barred from speaking
Immigration judges are employees of the Executive Office for Immigration Review, which falls under the DOJ's responsibility.
Policy restricts speech on immigration
The policy treats speech concerning agency policies as official-capacity speech, effectively prohibiting judges from speaking in their personal capacities about immigration or EOIR.
Judges' historical speech activities
Before 2017, judges regularly spoke at conferences, taught at universities, and participated in immigration law training.
Public access denied
The petition claims the policy denies the public access to important insights from those with direct knowledge of how the immigration system operates.
Holly D'Andrea's statement
Holly A. D'Andrea, president of NAIJ, says judges do not turn in their right to free speech when they put on the robe.
Supreme Court's prior intervention
The Supreme Court granted the government's petition and summarily reversed the Fourth Circuit's judgment in May.
The one thing
Immigration judges seek Supreme Court review of a DOJ policy that bars them from speaking publicly about immigration, claiming it violates their First Amendment rights.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.



