From SI · · 3m
Man Utd Manager Michael Carrick Faces Job Threat
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick may lose his job as club considers replacements after a poor season start.
In brief
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick may lose his job as club considers replacements after a poor season start. Manchester United manager Michael Carrick faces potential dismissal after a poor season start, with multiple candidates including Fabian Hürzeler, Antonio Conte, Kieran McKenna, Eddie Howe, Julian…
Michael Carrick under pressure
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick faces potential dismissal after a poor season start.
Internal division over replacement
Key figures at United are divided over who should replace Carrick, with technical director Jason Wilcox and recruitment chief Christopher Vivell pushing different candidates.
Jason Wilcox and Christopher Vivell at odds
Technical director Jason Wilcox, the target of Lisandro Martínez’s recent rant, is said to be at odds with recruitment chief Christopher Vivell.
Shortlist of six candidates
United have drawn up a shortlist that reportedly stretches to six candidates, though some are likely unattainable.
Fabian Hürzeler as top target
Fabian Hürzeler, Brighton’s manager, is reportedly United’s top target but would require a world-record fee to leave the club.
Hürzeler’s fee concerns
The Telegraph reports a 'world-record fee' would be needed to convince Hürzeler to terminate his contract with Brighton.
Hürzeler’s fee comparison
A fee of around $29 million took Julian Nagelsmann to Bayern Munich in April 2021, making Hürzeler’s potential move financially challenging.
Antonio Conte as contender
Antonio Conte, the former Napoli boss, is widely accepted as a potential replacement with immediate availability.
Conte’s management concerns
The Athletic points to potential concerns over Conte’s volatile management style and high-profile issues.
Kieran McKenna’s background
Kieran McKenna has similar connections to Carrick, having worked at United for five years including as scout and assistant to Ole Gunnar Solskjær.
McKenna’s availability
McKenna has been out of work since the summer after guiding Ipswich back to the Premier League.
Eddie Howe’s history with United
United have an uncomfortable history with Eddie Howe, who was pushed as a candidate by former sporting director Dan Ashworth in 2024.
Howe’s potential role
Technical director Jason Wilcox favors Howe and those with proven Premier League experience.
Howe’s readiness question
Howe has managed Newcastle in the Champions League but has not yet tested himself at a club with Old Trafford’s pressure.
Julian Nagelsmann’s background
Julian Nagelsmann worked his way up from Hoffenheim to RB Leipzig and Bayern Munich.
Nagelsmann as leading candidate
Reports have named Nagelsmann as a 'leading candidate' to replace Carrick, though Vivell answers to Wilcox.
Nagelsmann’s age and availability
Nagelsmann remains one of the most exciting young managers in the game and is immediately available after resigning his Germany national team post.
Unai Emery’s potential role
Unai Emery, Aston Villa’s manager, is a contender with Premier League experience but faces financial hurdles.
Emery’s financial concerns
Emery is under contract until 2029 and would likely require a record-breaking fee to leave Villa.
Emery’s management style concerns
There are concerns about the level of influence Emery would demand in a setup that favors the 'head coach' moniker.
The main idea
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick faces potential dismissal after a poor season start, with multiple candidates including Fabian Hürzeler, Antonio Conte, Kieran McKenna, Eddie Howe, Julian Nagelsmann, and Unai Emery.
