From Scroll · Harsh Mander · · 1m 30s
India's Scientific Temper Under Threat
India's scientific temper faces a crisis as superstition and unreason grow in public life.
In brief
India's scientific temper faces a crisis as superstition and unreason grow in public life. India's scientific temper is being undermined by rising superstition and unreason, leading to violence against rationalists. Originally reported by Scroll.
Scientific Temper in Constitution
India's constitution added scientific temper as a fundamental duty in 1976 through Article 51A(h).
“scientific temper, humanism, and the spirit of inquiry and reform”
Nehru's Scientific Temper
Nehru championed scientific temper as a path to freedom from caste, gender and religious discrimination.
“point(ing) out the way along which man should travel. It is the temper of a free man”
Nehru's 1934 Warning
Nehru warned that the absence of reason and its consequences like bigotry were India's chief enemy.
“our chief enemy today is (the) absence of reason, and its necessary consequence, bigotry”
Scientific Temper vs Religion
Scientific temper is not opposed to religious faith but challenges blind superstition and dogma.
“it questions superstitious belief and the promotion of unreasoning acceptance of received dogmas”
Historical Rationalists
Ancient Indian traditions like Buddhism and Jainism promoted rationalism against dogma.
“the charvaka philosophy around 600 bce laid emphasis on materialism to understand and live in the world”
Modern Rationalists
Social reformers like Ram Mohan Roy and Jotirao Phule championed rationalism for social change.
“the fact is that habit and training make men blind and deaf in spite of their own eyes and ears”
Nehru's Scientific Approach
Nehru argued science should be applied to all aspects of life including family, religion and society.
“science means an approach to all of life's problems. It is to be applied to the problems relating to our family, religion and everything else”
Modern India's Crisis
India's education system fails to foster critical thinking and encourages blind faith in tradition.
“today's education system in india often deprives young people of critical imagination and encourages uncritical faith in inherited tradition”
Superstition in Textbooks
India has removed Darwin's theory of evolution from official textbooks.
“india has gone further by eliminating in official textbooks any reference to darwin's theory of evolution”
Rationalist Violence
Rationalists fighting superstition have been killed by extremists since 2013.
“narendra dabholkar in 2013; govind pansare gunned down in february 2015, mm. kalburgi in 2015, and in 2017 journalist and social critic gauri lankesh”
Habib's Warning
Superstition is weaponized and propagated as wisdom, threatening science's future.
“the crisis today is not only one of religious bigotry and superstition, overwhelming the temper of science, but of the challenge posed by the spread of the culture of ignorance for the future of science”
The Battle for India
India's scientific temper battle is for the soul of the nation and future generations.
“if we fail, future generations will live in the shadow of superstition. if we prevail, we reclaim our heritage of reason and our right to think, question, and dream without fear”
The takeaway
India's scientific temper is being undermined by rising superstition and unreason, leading to violence against rationalists.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.




/file/attachments/orphans/visionquest-marvel3_233972.jpg)
