From Slate Magazine · Nicole Chung · · 50s
Brother Requests Expensive Gift for Niece
Brother asks for help buying niece an iPhone despite family objections.
In brief
Brother asks for help buying niece an iPhone despite family objections. A brother can buy his niece an iPhone without legal consequences if he avoids escalating family conflict. Originally reported by Slate Magazine.
Brother's Gift Request
My brother Ross wants me to buy his 11-year-old niece Bree an iPhone for Christmas.
Family Objection
My sister-in-law Zindy opposes Bree getting a phone until high school age.
Brother's Motivation
Ross believes buying the iPhone for Bree is a workaround to bypass Zindy's restrictions.
Personal Conflict
I dislike Zindy's treatment of people and am considering helping Ross despite family tensions.
Expert Advice
Slate's parenting expert warns against getting involved in family disputes over gifts.
The short version
A brother can buy his niece an iPhone without legal consequences if he avoids escalating family conflict.
