Copycat Disney Grey Stuff Recipe

This easy recipe recreates Disney's cookies-and-cream dessert for a themed treat.

“Try the grey stuff, it’s delicious!”

What is the Grey Stuff?

The Grey Stuff is a fluffy cookies-and-cream dessert popular at Disney World's Be Our Guest restaurant.

Disney's Grey Stuff Recipe

Disney has published its own Grey Stuff recipe, but Taste of Home's version uses pudding mix and Oreos for a similar flavor.

Ingredients for Copycat Grey Stuff

Use whole milk, vanilla pudding mix, chocolate fudge pudding mix, crushed Oreos, and thawed whipped topping for the best texture.

How to Make the Grey Stuff

Whisk milk and pudding mixes, fold in whipped topping and crushed Oreos, then pipe or spoon into glasses with toppings.

Recipe Variations

Add chocolate for extra flavor, try minty twists with peppermint extract, or customize toppings with chocolate curls and sprinkles.

How to Serve the Grey Stuff

Build mini parfaits, sandwich it between cookies, use as frosting, or serve as a dip for a themed dessert.

Storage and Preparation

Store in airtight container for up to four days; prepare up to one day ahead for best texture.

Dairy-Free and Gluten-Free Options

Use gluten-free Oreos and dairy-free alternatives for a vegan version of the dessert.

Why This Recipe Works

The recipe uses the right balance of pudding mixes and crushed Oreos for a fluffy, cookies-and-cream texture.

Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Sharon Lehman, RDN, with seven years of experience, tested this recipe for Taste of Home.

When to Try This Recipe

Enjoy this dessert for a Beauty and the Beast-themed movie night or when craving Disney vacation treats.