From The New Yorker · Jay Caspian Kang · · 3m
The case for radical rudeness online
We've accepted constant availability as a social norm. Breaking that pact might be the only way to escape our devices.
In brief
We've accepted constant availability as a social norm. Breaking that pact might be the only way to escape our devices. The author argues that constant digital availability is enforced by social obligation rather than addiction, and that resisting it requires deliberately breaking the unspoken rule that we must always…
Always connected, always anxious

In post-9/11 Manhattan, the author felt panic during subway rides without cell service, imagining disasters and people desperately trying to reach her. When service returned, anxiety about missed messages would follow.
The relief of brief disconnection
Moving to Brooklyn, the author's commute crossed the Gowanus Canal above ground, briefly restoring cell service. She recalls sending many unnecessary texts between Smith Street and Ninth Avenue during those years.
No respite from connection now
Today, cell service extends into subway tunnels and almost everywhere else. The author notes that while nobody particularly loves constant connection, we have come to think of it as a necessity.
The announcement of unavailability

When friends board planes without Wi-Fi, they announce it to group chats, even if they have not been part of recent conversations. The author wonders what prompts these announcements of temporary disconnection.
Breaking an unspoken pact
These announcements signal a temporary break from a tacit but ubiquitous pact that we will always be available for one another. This agreement occupies a place in the realm of manners in our personal lives.
Fear of rudeness, not missing out
The author's real worry when offline is not missing news but seeming rude by not answering.Fear of rudeness or indifference is more powerful than FOMO, which only applies to ourselves and which we can control.
Bradbury predicted this in 1953
Ray Bradbury's story The Murderer features a prisoner who destroys communication devices. When a diathermy machine scrambles devices on a bus, passengers face having to converse with each other, causing panic.
“Silence! A terrible, unexpected silence. The bus inhabitants faced with having to converse with each other. Panic! Sheer, animal panic!”
The problem is habit, not algorithms
Bradbury understood that the problem was not competition or FOMO but claggy connections formed out of habit and custom. It is the thousands of hands weakly reaching out, not asking for much but always asking.
Changing norms is harder than law
For those resisting technology's presence, understanding tech use as a social contract rather than clinical addiction presents more challenges than opportunity.It is harder to change social norms than to pass legislation banning phones in schools.
Resistance requires collective action
Actual material resistance probably has to take collective form, whether in class-action lawsuits, labor organizing, or data-center protests. Individual resistance alone cannot overcome the social obligation to reply.
Embrace radical rudeness
As individuals, we need to embrace radical rudeness: not answering text messages, not participating in WhatsApp groups, leaving people on read or not reading at all.Most people will not think much of your silence anyway.
“we will need to embrace a kind of radical rudeness, one in which we don't answer text messages, don't participate in WhatsApp groups, and leave pretty much everyone on read”
The key point
The author argues that constant digital availability is enforced by social obligation rather than addiction, and that resisting it requires deliberately breaking the unspoken rule that we must always reply.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.
/file/attachments/orphans/visionquest-marvel3_233972.jpg)


