From The New Yorker · Ishaan Tharoor · · 4m
Trump and Xi's competing visions for global power
As the Chinese president visits Washington, two leaders with starkly different worldviews are reshaping the international order.
In brief
As the Chinese president visits Washington, two leaders with starkly different worldviews are reshaping the international order. Trump and Xi both see themselves as restoring their nations' greatness, but their approaches, unilateral versus patient accumulation, are fundamentally reshaping global alliances and power…
Xi arrives as Trump's honored guest

The Chinese president lands at Joint Base Andrews on Wednesday, greeted on the tarmac by Trump himself. This marks the first state visit from China's leader in a decade, with a full military ceremony planned at the White House.
Trump's China stance has softened dramatically
After initially framing China as a strategic rival in his first term, Trump has backed down on tariffs and delayed arms sales to Taiwan. He's now praising Xi as a great gentleman with whom he has a very good relationship.
“He's a great gentleman. We get along great. We have a very good trading relationship.”
China controls critical minerals the West needs
In April of last year, China responded to Trump's tariffs by restricting exports of critical minerals that U.S. companies depend on. Trump immediately backtracked, demonstrating China's economic leverage.
Summit outcomes remain uncertain despite pomp

Possible agreements include a formal U.S.-China dialogue on artificial intelligence and extending a trade truce from October. But expectations for tangible results are low, with deep distrust underlying the personal rapport.
Xi faces mounting domestic economic troubles
The Chinese president arrives in Washington dealing with sluggish economic growth and stubbornly high youth unemployment at home. The state visit offers him a chance to project strength and stability.
Trump rejects multilateralism at the U.N.
At the General Assembly, Trump attacked the U.N.'s globalist bureaucrats and human-rights council, celebrating American military might and unilateral action. He mused about driving Iran into hell and touted his operation to remove Maduro in Venezuela.
“Do I drive them into hell with no chance of survival and no hope of future greatness or generations?”
Other leaders champion multilateralism
Brazil's Lula, Canada's Mark Carney, Kenya's William Ruto, and Europe's António Costa argued that sovereignty is strengthened through collective action on shared challenges. This vision directly opposes Trump's unilateral approach.
“Sovereignty is strengthened, not diminished, when countries work together to address shared challenges.”
China positions itself as the responsible alternative
Xi toured Central Asia and South Asia casting China as a driver of multilateralism and a responsible major country. Beijing criticizes American hegemonism while claiming to champion the Global South against Western economic domination.
Developing nations are hedging against Washington
Countries in the Global South can't ignore China's economic footprint as their biggest trading partner, but they're also wary of Beijing's designs. They're trying to balance between an unreliable Washington and an economically dominant China.
Trump and Xi see themselves as history's chosen ones
Both leaders regard themselves as seminal figures appointed by history to restore their nations' greatness after predecessors squandered it through corruption and ineptness. This messianic self-image drives their competing visions.
Trump dismantles alliances, Xi prefers great-power talks
Trump has smashed the trust of close U.S. allies with coercive tactics, seeing Beijing and Moscow as starting points for diplomacy rather than allied nations. This approach suits China, which is averse to treaty alliances but eager for great-power shoulder-rubbing.
Xi consolidates power through party purges
Xi's primary focus is consolidating and extending his own power within the Communist Party through ruthless purges of cadres. His international agenda is secondary to maintaining control at home.
China views America as declining but dangerous
Beijing sees the United States as a weakening power that remains militarily threatening. Xi is content to patiently accumulate influence until China is recognized as leader of a new political order.
Trump is an easy mark for Beijing
China has found an unwitting accomplice in Trump, who is giving ground on sensitive issues like chip export controls and Taiwan policy. Beijing's real objective is to contain worst outcomes and pursue regional expansion elsewhere.
The headline
Trump and Xi both see themselves as restoring their nations' greatness, but their approaches, unilateral versus patient accumulation, are fundamentally reshaping global alliances and power dynamics.




