From The Verge · Nilay Patel · · 5m
How Democrats won where Musk's X lost
New Jersey governor Mikie Sherrill explains how her state's midterm victory proved that social media bubbles don't match reality, and why state power is rising as federal regulation fails.
In brief
New Jersey governor Mikie Sherrill explains how her state's midterm victory proved that social media bubbles don't match reality, and why state power is rising as federal regulation fails. Governor Mikie Sherrill credits her New Jersey victory to running on affordability and accountability, arguing that despite tech…
New Jersey's bellwether moment

Mikie Sherrill, New Jersey governor for under a year, says her state's election was a preview of huge Democratic victories in recent midterms because she ran on affordability and accountability.
Corruption became the animating issue
Corruption ranked as the number two issue in polling, surprising analysts. Sherrill heard anger about it on the campaign trail, tied to Trump pocketing billions while voters' costs rose.
Tech billionaires control the media
Elon Musk owns X, Larry Ellison and Oracle have a controlling stake in TikTok, Mark Zuckerberg owns Instagram, and Skydance owns CNN. Yet voters still learned about corruption.
Specific corruption was hard to communicate

Congress blocked high-end semiconductor chips to compete with China, then Trump got paid off by the UAE and floodgates opened for cryptocurrency into his pocketbooks, Sherrill says.
Transparency beats cover-ups
New Jersey discovered the last administration had registered non-citizens on voter rolls without clearing them. Sherrill chose transparency over hiding it, saying strong leadership means owning problems and fixing them.
You can't hide from the American people
Sherrill believes the internet means politicians cannot sweep things under the rug anymore. If she had hidden the voter roll problem, the narrative would have gotten out anyway, told by others.
Influencer politics is here to stay
Politicians like New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani have learned the visual and social vernacular of influencers. Sherrill says authenticity matters more than followers, and performative toughness backfires.
Zohran Mamdani's gift for connection
Sherrill praises Mamdani as a social media prodigy who connects policy to results with humanity and empathy. She says she won't match his following but focuses on authentic engagement with her electorate.
X feels toxic now
The newer generation of winning politicians operate on Instagram with native video, not on X. Sherrill says X just feels toxic, especially since Elon took it over.
Elon's Twitter purchase was a failure
X is smaller than Twitter used to be, makes less money, and has lost political influence. It no longer drives the national political conversation the way it once did.
X created a false bubble
Sherrill says X gives a false sense of where people actually are. Astroturf campaigns create fake grassroots energy online, but ground-level campaigning reveals the real pulse of voters.
Bravado feels very 2024
JD Vance's post distancing himself from Trump and Pete Hegseth's video saying go ahead and impeach me feel like pure X, talking to one small audience. That energy is fading as young supporters face joblessness.
Power moves to the states
As Trump concentrated power in the executive branch and Congress was co-opted, power moved to governors and state legislatures. Sherrill sees Democratic governors in California, Texas, New York, and New Jersey wielding new influence.
New Jersey blocked Russian diesel
Trump said he would purchase Russian diesel.Sherrill opposed it because Russia funds Iran, which the US is at war with.She put every port and business on notice it was illegal under laws Congress passed.
States are exercising dormant power
A couple of ships turned away from New Jersey ports. Sherrill says states have tools they haven't exercised in this way in a long time, and this muscle is now being flexed.
New Jersey restructured its government
Sherrill added a chief operating officer to her administration. New Jersey would be the twenty-second largest economy in the world if it were a country, yet Trenton had not operated that way.
Government must protect people from downside risks
Sherrill says government has been absent from the AI and data center conversation. Companies are built to make money, innovators to innovate, but government should protect people from downside risks.
Data centers need a better business model
Sherrill froze rate hikes on day one and expanded power generation. She wants data centers to show communities what they will look like, how loud they are, and how much water and energy they use.
States are laboratories of democracy on AI
Federal regulation is not happening for a couple more years.States are coalescing around similar guardrails: community benefits, energy and water reporting, bring your own power, good jobs.This pressure could help create a consistent national scheme.
The main idea
Governor Mikie Sherrill credits her New Jersey victory to running on affordability and accountability, arguing that despite tech billionaires controlling media platforms, voters discovered corruption through direct engagement, and states are now exercising power in AI policy that the federal government has abandoned.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.


