From Vox · Miles Bryan · · 3m
Men weren't always bad at friendship
Historian Tiffany Watt Smith explains how male friendships were once celebrated as the deepest human bonds, and what changed.
In brief
Historian Tiffany Watt Smith explains how male friendships were once celebrated as the deepest human bonds, and what changed. Male friendships were historically considered the most intimate and meaningful bonds; gender roles inverted in the nineteenth century, but history shows friendship can change again. Originally…
The male friendship debate
Writers and academics worry about rising male loneliness and its impact on society. Others defend male friendships built around shared activities rather than emotional intimacy.
A historian's perspective
Historian Tiffany Watt Smith, who has published books on the histories of friendship and emotions, offers a different way to think about the debate.
Men were friendship experts

For thousands of years, men were considered the great experts in forming the highest kinds of friendships and the most intimate bonds.
Aristotle's perfect friendship
Aristotle in the fourth-century BC described the deepest friendship as between two men who are soulmates. He saw other friendships as lesser kinds.
Montaigne on male bonds
Sixteenth-century essayist Michel de Montaigne wrote about his close friendship with La Boétie as an ideal meeting of souls, rare and extraordinary.
Women excluded from perfection
Montaigne explicitly said women were incapable of perfect friendship, lacking emotional stamina, cleverness, education and strong enough souls.
“Women are just incapable of having this kind of perfect friendship. They don't have the kind of emotional stamina. They're not clever enough.”
Romantic friendship defined
Historians call intimate male friendships romantic friendship. These men saw themselves as partners, sometimes calling their bond a marriage of soul.
Two doctors, one tomb
Two sixteenth-century doctors at Christ's College in Cambridge lived their whole lives together, traveled and researched together, and were buried together.
The eighteenth-century shift
Beginning in the eighteenth century and certainly by the nineteenth, public and private spheres divided. The male sphere became rational and public, the female intimate and emotional.
Women's friendships idealized
A new ideal of femininity emerged as a middle-class goal. Young girls were taught romantic, committed, caring friendships as training for motherhood and marriage.
Male friendships diminished
By the end of the nineteenth century, male friendships were portrayed as blundering, superficial and lacking intimacy, a complete inversion from centuries before.
Homosexuality and anxiety
A rise in understanding of homosexuality across Europe and America made men anxious about intimate relationships with other men and how they might be read.
Friendship can change again
Smith says history shows friendship has changed before and can change again. There is nothing biologically innate about men's inability to make close friends.
“Since friendship has changed in the past, it can change again. There's nothing biologically innate about the inability to make friends.”
Negotiating friendship individually
Each friendship is singular and requires negotiation. Men can work out their own style of friendship and find common ground with others.
“Friendship is something that we have to negotiate on an individual basis. Each friendship is completely singular and we have to work out its rules.”
In short
Male friendships were historically considered the most intimate and meaningful bonds; gender roles inverted in the nineteenth century, but history shows friendship can change again.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.
/file/attachments/orphans/visionquest-marvel3_233972.jpg)



