# 8 New Fall Romance Books Goodreads Readers Are Loving

> Goodreads readers recommend eight cozy fall romances with witches, small towns and second chances.
- Title: 8 New Fall Romance Books Goodreads Readers Are Loving
- Summary: Goodreads readers recommend eight cozy fall romances with witches, small towns and second chances. Goodreads users highlight eight new romance books perfect…
- Keywords: goodreads, romance, fall, small town, witches, second chance, cozy romance, new york city, tuscany, glenridge, claire, matteo lucchese
- Source: Woman's World — https://womansworld.com/entertainment/books/8-best-new-fall-romance-books-according-to-goodreads
- Author: Carissa Mosness
- Published: 2026-10-06T21:30:39+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: goodreads, romance, fall, small town, witches, second chance, cozy romance, new york city, tuscany, glenridge, claire, matteo lucchese
## Goodreads Readers' Top Fall Romance Picks
Goodreads users recommend eight new romance books perfect for fall reading with witches, small towns and second chances.
## Something About September by Julia McKay
Putnam publishes Julia McKay's small-town second-chance romance where Rebecca must renovate her grandmother's diner in 30 days with her high school crush.
## Take a Chance Sasha Sinclair by Ashley Herring Blake
Ashley Herring Blake's Clover Lake series follows Sasha Sinclair uncovering the Rose Witch's history with her family in North Carolina.
## Under the Orchard's Spell by Ann Adams
Ann Adams' novel features Ali Reid inheriting a pear orchard and working with her former lover Logan to uncover dark magic.
## The Magic We Made by Meg Cabot
Meg Cabot's witchy romance follows Frankie Giovanni, a science-loving skeptic in West Harbor, Connecticut, who teams up with Ash Merit to find missing teens.
## Trust Fall by Lynn Painter
Lynn Painter's New York City novel follows Julia inheriting a brownstone and a private school spot from her neighbor, with her tutor Damien.
## The Fall Affair by Vi Keeland
Vi Keeland's Tuscany novel follows Allegra Bianchi escaping New York to fall in love with winemaker Matteo Lucchese.
## Season for Falling by Kate O'Shaughnessy
Kate O'Shaughnessy's Glenridge novel follows Claire saving for NYU with her former co-star Luke Cordova who offers to pay for her college.
## Love Felt Like This by Julie Olivia
Julie Olivia's children's show romance features singer Griffin Harvey and children's TV producer Beverly Lark working together on a show.
## Goodreads User Reviews
Readers praise the books for cozy small-town charm, magical elements, emotional healing and second chances.
## Why These Books?
These books offer witches, small towns, second chances and swoon-worthy romance perfect for fall reading.
## Fall Reading List
Goodreads users recommend these eight new romances for fall with heart, humor and magical elements.
## What Makes Them Special?
Each book features unique settings, characters and themes that resonate with readers seeking comfort and connection.
## Why Fall?
The cooler weather and cozy vibes make these romance books ideal for fall reading.
## Key takeaway

Goodreads users highlight eight new romance books perfect for fall reading, featuring small towns, witches and second chances.