# Best Cast-Iron Skillets After Years of Testing

> Lancaster and Victoria cast-iron skillets top Bon Appétit's side-by-side testing for nonstick performance and durability.
- Title: Best Cast-Iron Skillets After Years of Testing · Bon Appétit
- Summary: Lancaster and Victoria cast-iron skillets top Bon Appétit's side-by-side testing for nonstick performance and durability. Lancaster No.
- Keywords: cast-iron skillet, lancaster skillet, victoria skillet, bon appetit, nonstick performance, seasoning durability, cast-iron care, Bon Appétit
- URL: https://shortify.news/Bon_App%C3%A9tit/best-cast-iron-skillets-after-years-of-testing
- Source: Bon Appétit — https://bonappetit.com/story/best-cast-iron-skillet
- Author: Wilder Davies
- Published: 2021-06-16T16:00:00+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: cast-iron skillet, lancaster skillet, victoria skillet, bon appetit, nonstick performance, seasoning durability, cast-iron care, food, lifestyle
## Why cast-iron skillets matter
Cast-iron pans improve with use, becoming more nonstick over time through oil polymerization.
## The two main cast-iron fanbases
Some loyal to affordable USA-made Lodge, others to vintage Griswold or Wagner pans restored with DIY electrolysis.
## Our testing goal
Provide recommendations based on side-by-side testing and staff input, not changing loyalists' minds.
## Top pick: Lancaster No. 8 Skillet
Lancaster No. 8 Skillet is the lightest cast-iron pan tested, heats quickly, and has a smooth cooking surface.
## Lancaster's pros and cons
Pros: lightweight, smooth cooking surface, heats quickly, two pour spouts. Cons: pricey, preseasoning could be more robust.
## Lancaster's seasoning performance
Factory seasoning is smooth but not as robust as Lodge or Victoria pans; stains develop as seasoning matures.
## Lancaster's long-term care
Stains fade with continued use; seasoning can be restored by cooking with the pan without additional maintenance.
## Top pick: Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet
Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet offers affordable pricing with good nonstick performance and a comfortable handle design.
## Victoria's pros and cons
Pros: affordable, two pour spouts, helper handle, comes preseasoned. Cons: heavier than Lancaster.
## Victoria's factory seasoning
Victoria pans have a slicker factory seasoning than Lodge, making eggs and potatoes easier to fry without oil.
## How we tested cast-iron pans
Staff tested pans for maneuverability, nonstick performance, heat distribution, and seasoning durability.
## Why cast-iron is better than nonstick
Cast-iron pans are durable, retain heat well, and sear food without degrading over time unlike modern nonstick coatings.
## Other good cast-iron skillets
Stargazer, Yeti, Lodge, Smithey, and Field Company skillets offer quality but vary in weight and seasoning durability.
## Cast-iron skillets we don't recommend
Camp Chef, Valor, Finex, KitchenAid, Barebones, Victoria Signature Series, Cuisinel, Backcountry, Müeller, and Utopia Kitchen skillets have flaws in design or performance.
## How to care for cast-iron skillets
Wipe with damp cloth, dry thoroughly, apply light oil after cooking to prevent rust and maintain seasoning.
## Long-term cast-iron care
Rust spots can be fixed with salt scrub or vinegar soak; seasoning improves with continued use.
## Key takeaway

Lancaster No. 8 Skillet and Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet win Bon Appétit's testing for best nonstick cast-iron skillet performance and longevity.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Bon_App%C3%A9tit/best-cast-iron-skillets-after-years-of-testing
Reporting: Bon Appétit — https://bonappetit.com/story/best-cast-iron-skillet

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.