# Burnham's welfare gamble: five Labour groups to watch

> As the new prime minister pursues welfare reform, five key Labour factions will shape whether his plans survive where Starmer's failed.
- Title: Burnham's welfare gamble: five Labour groups to watch
- Summary: As the new prime minister pursues welfare reform, five key Labour factions will shape whether his plans survive where Starmer's failed.
- Keywords: andy burnham, keir starmer, alan milburn, welfare reform, labour party, meg hillier, debbie abrahams, youth unemployment, POLITICO
- URL: https://shortify.news/POLITICO/burnhams-welfare-gamble-five-labour-groups-to-watch
- Source: POLITICO — https://politico.eu/article/5-labour-group-matter-andy-burnham-welfare-social-security
- Published: 2026-11-17T18:04:31+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: andy burnham, keir starmer, alan milburn, welfare reform, labour party, meg hillier, debbie abrahams, youth unemployment, politics, world
## Starmer's welfare reform failed
Keir Starmer's attempt to tackle rising working-age sickness and disability benefit claims collapsed after Labour MPs rebelled. Andy Burnham must avoid the same fate.
## Milburn proposes youth welfare changes
Former Cabinet minister Alan Milburn published a review on Tuesday proposing changes to disability benefits for young people, a legal right to education or employment, and National Insurance cuts for retail and hospitality workers aged…
## The cost and timeline
Milburn's proposals would cost five point eight billion pounds a year, offset by six billion pounds in savings. A white paper and legislation are not due until next year.
## Committee chairs blocked Starmer's plans
Treasury Committee Chair Meg Hillier and Work and Pensions Committee Chair Debbie Abrahams led the rebellion that forced Starmer to roll back plans to reduce personal independence payments in two thousand twenty-five.
## Hillier and Abrahams signal cautious support
Hillier said Milburn had done very good work and she was giving him a fair wind. Abrahams called the proposals the opportunity of a generation, welcoming Milburn's rigorous analysis on why young people become NEETs.

> opportunity of a generation
## Ministers bound by collective responsibility
Chancellor John Healey, Louise Haigh and Vicky Foxcroft, all involved in blocking Starmer's reforms, now sit in Cabinet and must support government policy. Their words on welfare will be closely scrutinized.
## Backbenchers welcome but warn
Marie Tidball and Rachael Maskell, who rebelled against Starmer, welcomed Milburn's messaging that there won't be crude cuts to benefits.

> won't be crude cuts to benefits
## Gordon Brown watches from the sidelines
Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown, a Labour authority on welfare, previously warned that reducing social security leaves people in poverty. Any intervention by him would carry significant weight.
## Starmer veterans know the difficulty
Former Chancellor Rachel Reeves and former work and pensions secretary Liz Kendall, who experienced welfare reform's challenges under Starmer, will be watched for their response to Burnham's plans.
## Key takeaway

Andy Burnham is pursuing welfare reform through Alan Milburn's review, but must navigate Labour MPs who blocked similar plans under Keir Starmer.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/POLITICO/burnhams-welfare-gamble-five-labour-groups-to-watch
Reporting: POLITICO — https://politico.eu/article/5-labour-group-matter-andy-burnham-welfare-social-security

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.