# Canadian couple wins legal battle to keep unauthorized deck

> Canadian couple keeps wooden deck at BC resort after appeals court rejects demolition order.
- Title: Canadian couple wins legal battle to keep unauthorized deck
- Summary: Canadian couple keeps wooden deck at BC resort after appeals court rejects demolition order.
- Keywords: valley's edge resort, british columbia, moira holden, denis holden, deck, appeals court, demolition, 5000 payment, india, Indiatimes
- URL: https://shortify.news/Indiatimes/canadian-couple-wins-legal-battle-to-keep-unauthorized-deck
- Source: Indiatimes — https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/rest-of-world/a-canadian-couple-built-a-deck-at-their-british-columbia-resort-cabin-without-written-approval-their-resort-manager-wanted-it-demolished-but-a-november-13-appeals-ruling-let-it-stay-with-a-5000-payment/articleshow/135947953.cms
- Author: TOI World Desk
- Published: 2026-11-18T21:30:00+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: valley's edge resort, british columbia, moira holden, denis holden, deck, appeals court, demolition, 5000 payment, india, news
## Unauthorized deck construction
A Canadian couple built a wooden deck beside their holiday cabin without written approval at Valley’s Edge Resort in British Columbia.
## Resort manager's demand for removal
The resort manager wanted the deck demolished after the couple completed construction without obtaining required written permission.
## November 13 appeals ruling
A November 13 appeals ruling let the deck stay with a $5,000 payment instead of demolition.
## Legal dispute background
The dispute began when the couple approached the strata council in 2022 with deck plans that the council said they lacked authority to approve.
## 30-day deadline for action
Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. gave the couple 30 days to either dismantle the deck or submit a complete application for approval.
## Hand-drawn submission rejected
The couple submitted a hand-drawn diagram but the company’s president rejected it as incomplete.
## First court's decision
The judge found the company’s president had not clearly explained what information was missing from the application.
## Deck's environmental fit
The court considered the deck's appearance and impact, finding it consistent with the cabin and resort environment.
## No neighbor impact
The court found no evidence the deck prevented neighboring property owners from accessing or enjoying their lots.
## Resort's precedent argument
The resort administrator argued allowing the structure to remain would set an undesirable precedent for other property owners.
## Court's financial decision
The court ordered the couple to pay $5,000 in damages instead of demolishing the deck.
## Original damages claim
Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. sought $20,000 in damages while the couple argued they spent only $1,800 building the deck.
## Appeal decision
The British Columbia Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals, upholding the $5,000 damages award.
## Costs order
The court ordered each side to pay the other’s costs for defending the appeal at Scale A.
## Legal consequences
The ruling reinforces that property owners cannot disregard construction approval requirements even when demolition is unnecessary.
## Key takeaway

Moira and Denis Holden kept their unauthorized wooden deck at Valley’s Edge Resort in British Columbia after a November 13 appeals ruling awarded $5,000 in damages instead of demolition.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Indiatimes/canadian-couple-wins-legal-battle-to-keep-unauthorized-deck
Reporting: Indiatimes — https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/rest-of-world/a-canadian-couple-built-a-deck-at-their-british-columbia-resort-cabin-without-written-approval-their-resort-manager-wanted-it-demolished-but-a-november-13-appeals-ruling-let-it-stay-with-a-5000-payment/articleshow/135947953.cms

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.