# Elephant culls: manufactured emergency or management failure?

> South African authorities push to cull thousands of elephants in reserves, but conservationists say lethal measures are being used to cover up failures to implement non-lethal alternatives.
- Title: Elephant culls: manufactured emergency or management failure?
- Summary: South African authorities push to cull thousands of elephants in reserves, but conservationists say lethal measures are being used to cover up failures to…
- Keywords: elephant culling, north west parks, ezemvelo kzn wildlife, immunocontraception, wildlife management, south africa, madikwe game reserve, animal welfare, conservation, national environmental management biodiv, Daily Maverick
- URL: https://shortify.news/Daily_Maverick/elephant-culls-manufactured-emergency-or-management-failure
- Source: Daily Maverick — https://dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2026-11-17-manufactured-emergencies-convenient-failures-why-sas-elephant-culls-demand-accountability
- Author: Stephanie Klarmann
- Published: 2026-11-17T21:30:59+00:00
- Read time: 3 min
- Topics: elephant culling, north west parks, ezemvelo kzn wildlife, immunocontraception, wildlife management, south africa, madikwe game reserve, animal welfare, conservation, national environmental management biodiv, news, politics
## Authorities push for mass elephant culls
Nature conservation authorities in North West and KwaZulu-Natal are pushing to cull thousands of elephants in fenced reserves despite objections from conservationists and animal welfare specialists.
## The numbers being proposed
Ian Rushworth, scientific manager at Ezemvelo, proposed removing one thousand two hundred twenty elephants from fenced reserves in KwaZulu-Natal. North West authorities are advocating removal of one thousand elephants from Madikwe alone over five years.
## Non-lethal option was never implemented
North West authorities failed to implement immunocontraceptive interventions dating back to two thousand twenty. If implemented on time, reproductive control of breeding herds in Madikwe would have been achieved by two thousand twenty-six.
## Commercial trade justifies culling, officials claim
During a presentation to the Portfolio Committee on Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, Rushworth justified culling by citing a whole industry of elephant skins, meat and ivory carvings, claiming this trade boom makes non-lethal alternatives…
## What South African law actually requires
South Africa's National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act and National Norms and Standards for the Management of Elephants govern culling decisions. An approved elephant management plan alone does not authorise culling.
## Culling is a last resort, not first option
The National Norms and Standards state culling may only be implemented after other population management options have been considered, evaluated and rejected.
## Four legal requirements before any cull
Decisions to cull must be informed by ecological necessity, evaluation of why alternatives were rejected, implementation plans detailing removal numbers and methods, and animal wellbeing considerations addressing physical and mental health of elephants.
## Elephants are sentient, welfare matters
Elephants are recognised as sentient and highly social animals. Animal wellbeing is now an integral part of South Africa's Biodiversity Act and must be included in any decision-making regarding biodiversity conservation and ecosystem protection.

> We cannot selectively ignore the science of sentience of welfare and wellbeing.
## Culling causes severe animal suffering
Karen Trendler, wildlife welfare specialist, explains that placement of heart and brain, skull thickness and herd behaviour present significant challenges.

> Even with expert marksmen, using the correct ammunition and weapons, and good planning, not all elephants are killed outright.
## North West failed to deliver on agreement
North West Parks concluded an agreement in two thousand twenty-two with Humane World for Animals South Africa to provide immunocontraception but failed to implement the programme. Officials have acknowledged this as a missed opportunity.
## KwaZulu-Natal lacks ecological evidence
In July two thousand twenty-six, Ezemvelo proposed removing one thousand two hundred twenty elephants, yet elephant management plans for the province expired in two thousand twenty-two and updated plans are still in progress or awaiting…
## Implementation barriers are administrative, not technical
Dr Audrey Delsink, senior director of wildlife at Humane World for Animals SA, says barriers to immunocontraception are administrative, institutional and policy-related rather than technical.

> The barriers appear to be administrative, institutional and policy-related rather than technical.
## Kruger shows alternatives to culling work
Kruger National Park ceased routine culling in nineteen ninety-four, shifting to manipulating water distribution and elephant landscape use instead.
## Accountability must come before culling
Dr Delsink identifies a severe lack of accountability resulting in manufactured emergency caused by delayed agreements, weak accountability for implementation, poor inter-agency coordination, insufficient transparency and limited public consultation.

> Delayed agreements, weak accountability for implementation, poor inter-agency coordination, insufficient transparency, limited public consultation, and failure to translate national policy commitments into reserve management plans and practical action.
## Authorities must prove necessity before culling
Before North West Parks and Ezemvelo decide to cull elephants, they must explain what ecological problems they are solving, what evidence substantiates the problem and why all options required by their own management framework have…
## Key takeaway

North West and KwaZulu-Natal authorities are proposing to cull thousands of elephants without fully implementing non-lethal alternatives required by law, raising questions about whether the emergency is real or manufactured.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Daily_Maverick/elephant-culls-manufactured-emergency-or-management-failure
Reporting: Daily Maverick — https://dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2026-11-17-manufactured-emergencies-convenient-failures-why-sas-elephant-culls-demand-accountability

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.