# Etsy vs Five Below: 2026 Stock Comparison

> Etsy and Five Below: Which consumer stock offers better growth and value in 2026?
- Title: Etsy vs Five Below: 2026 Stock Comparison · The Motley Fool
- Summary: Etsy and Five Below: Which consumer stock offers better growth and value in 2026? Five Below's lower valuation and higher growth prospects make it the better…
- Keywords: etsy, five below, consumer stocks, 2026, growth, valuation, revenue, finance, money, Five, Below, Stock
- Source: The Motley Fool — https://fool.com/coverage/better-buy/2026/10/21/etsy-vs-five-below-which-consumer-stock-is-a-better-buy-in-2026
- Author: Jake Lerch
- Published: 2026-10-21T17:30:02+00:00
- Read time: 1 min
- Topics: etsy, five below, consumer stocks, 2026, growth, valuation, revenue, finance, money
## Etsy Overview
Etsy operates a digital platform connecting nearly 87 million buyers with creative sellers.
## Five Below Overview
Five Below targets teens and families with value-priced products across 1,900 stores.
## Financial Metrics
Etsy has a market cap of $7.7B with a gross margin of 72.62%, while Five Below has a $13B market cap and 36.49% gross margin.
## Etsy Performance
Etsy reported $2.9 billion revenue in FY 2025 with a net margin of 5.7%.
## Five Below Performance
Five Below achieved $4.8 billion revenue in FY 2025 with a net margin of 7.5%.
## Growth Comparison
Five Below has averaged 15.9% quarterly revenue growth over five years versus Etsy's 5.4%.
## Profitability
Etsy has a five-year average operating margin of 15.5%, while Five Below's is 10.7%.
## Valuation
Five Below's current P/E multiple is 20x, while Etsy's is 52x, making Five Below the better value.
## Key takeaway

Five Below's lower valuation and higher growth prospects make it the better 2026 buy over Etsy.