# EU accused of cooking Egypt welfare figures

> Leaked documents suggest the European Commission overstated Egypt's progress on social welfare to release two point five billion euros in loans.
- Title: EU accused of cooking Egypt welfare figures · the Guardian
- Summary: Leaked documents suggest the European Commission overstated Egypt's progress on social welfare to release two point five billion euros in loans.
- Keywords: european commission, egypt, ursula von der leyen, abdel fatah al-sisi, macro-financial assistance, welfare programmes, human rights, tineke strik, takaful, karama, the Guardian
- URL: https://shortify.news/the_Guardian/eu-accused-of-cooking-egypt-welfare-figures
- Source: the Guardian — https://theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/18/european-commission-accused-sugarcoating-figures-egypt-loans
- Published: 2026-11-18T05:00:32+00:00
- Read time: 3 min
- Topics: european commission, egypt, ursula von der leyen, abdel fatah al-sisi, macro-financial assistance, welfare programmes, human rights, tineke strik, takaful, karama
## Seven point four billion euro deal with Egypt
Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, promised Abdel Fatah al-Sisi a seven point four billion euro strategic partnership during a high-profile visit to Cairo in 2024.
## Deal aimed at economy, migration and region
The three-year partnership was intended to bolster Egypt's shaky economy, deter migrants from coming to Europe and shore up a region reeling from the seven October attacks and Israel's war on Gaza.
## Five billion in soft loans with conditions
Five billion euros in EU soft loans, with easy repayment terms known as macro-financial assistance, were meant to be available only to countries respecting human rights and democracy.
## Commission claimed Egypt met welfare targets
The European Commission told EU lawmakers that Egypt had fulfilled targets to increase poor people on social welfare programmes, enabling release of two point five billion euros in assistance.
## But welfare rolls actually shrank
Leaked EU documents and data deleted from an Egyptian government website show a net reduction of eighty five thousand seven hundred thirty four households removed from welfare programmes rather than added.
## The two welfare programmes involved
Takaful gives poor families cash payments if recipients have regular health visits and school attendance. Karama gives unconditional cash to people with disabilities, older people, orphans and widows.
## First target: add one hundred thousand households
One EU condition for the first one billion euro loan was to increase Takaful and Karama beneficiary households by one hundred thousand to four point seven million.
## Commission called it broadly fulfilled
The commission described the target as broadly fulfilled in a leaked report to EU lawmakers, but data revealed a net fall of sixty two thousand two hundred eighty one households due to a recertification process.
## Second target: add sixty thousand more households
For a later one point five billion euro instalment, Egypt was required to further expand the programmes, adding sixty thousand households to the Takaful and Karama beneficiaries list.
## Commission said target was fulfilled
A second leaked report shows the commission concluded the target was fulfilled because four hundred forty two thousand one hundred eighteen families were added to the list.
## But actual numbers fell again
Figures from Egypt's ministry of social solidarity show a net reduction of twenty three thousand four hundred fifty three beneficiaries in the eleven months until June twenty twenty six, leading up to the payment.
## MEP Tineke Strik demands clarification
Dutch MEP Tineke Strik, a leading voice on EU-Egypt relations, said the commission sugarcoating Egypt's performance was worrying and introduced a question demanding clarification from the commission.

> The finding by this investigation that the commission is seemingly sugarcoating Egypt's performance is worrying.
## Concerns about vague human rights conditions
Critics say if the EU cannot enforce clear economic targets, its vague democracy and human rights conditions are meaningless and amount to a blank cheque for Egypt's authoritarianism.

> Without benchmarks, the EU has turned a human rights conditionality into a blank cheque for Egypt's authoritarianism.
## Commission defends its position
The European Commission said targets referred to new beneficiary families, not net increases, and that compliance is examined thoroughly by EU officials and diplomats based on information from Egyptian authorities and other sources.
## Final payment of one point five billion pending
Egypt has received three point five billion euros in three instalments so far. The final one point five billion euro payment is expected before the end of twenty twenty seven once all conditions are met.
## Key takeaway

The European Commission released two point five billion euros to Egypt despite data showing welfare rolls shrank, not grew as required.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/the_Guardian/eu-accused-of-cooking-egypt-welfare-figures
Reporting: the Guardian — https://theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/18/european-commission-accused-sugarcoating-figures-egypt-loans

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.