# Immigration Judges Challenge Supreme Court on Free Speech

> Immigration judges appeal to Supreme Court over First Amendment restrictions on public speech.
- Title: Immigration Judges Challenge Supreme Court on Free Speech
- Summary: Immigration judges appeal to Supreme Court over First Amendment restrictions on public speech.
- Keywords: immigration judges, first amendment, department of justice, national association of immigration judg, supreme court, federal court, civil service review, first amendment black hole, Newsweek
- URL: https://shortify.news/Newsweek/immigration-judges-challenge-supreme-court-on-free-speech
- Source: Newsweek — https://newsweek.com/immigration-judges-first-amendment-appeal-supreme-court-12729314
- Published: 2026-11-17T21:14:18+00:00
- Read time: 1 min
- Topics: immigration judges, first amendment, department of justice, national association of immigration judg, supreme court, federal court, civil service review, first amendment black hole
## Immigration judges file First Amendment appeal
Immigration judges ask Supreme Court to review a DOJ policy restricting their public speech on immigration.
## NAIJ petitions Supreme Court for review
The National Association of Immigration Judges filed a petition Tuesday to have the Supreme Court review an appeals court ruling that prevents them from challenging the policy directly in federal district court.
## First Amendment injury claimed
Judges argue that forcing them to wait while the policy remains in place creates an immediate First Amendment injury by chilling speech before it even happens.
## Knight Institute's legal stance
Ramya Krishnan, senior staff attorney for the Knight First Amendment Institute, says public employees should be able to challenge government speech restraints immediately.
## Immigration judges barred from speaking
Immigration judges are employees of the Executive Office for Immigration Review, which falls under the DOJ's responsibility.
## Policy restricts speech on immigration
The policy treats speech concerning agency policies as official-capacity speech, effectively prohibiting judges from speaking in their personal capacities about immigration or EOIR.
## Judges' historical speech activities
Before 2017, judges regularly spoke at conferences, taught at universities, and participated in immigration law training.
## Public access denied
The petition claims the policy denies the public access to important insights from those with direct knowledge of how the immigration system operates.
## Holly D'Andrea's statement
Holly A. D'Andrea, president of NAIJ, says judges do not turn in their right to free speech when they put on the robe.
## Supreme Court's prior intervention
The Supreme Court granted the government's petition and summarily reversed the Fourth Circuit's judgment in May.
## Key takeaway

Immigration judges seek Supreme Court review of a DOJ policy that bars them from speaking publicly about immigration, claiming it violates their First Amendment rights.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Newsweek/immigration-judges-challenge-supreme-court-on-free-speech
Reporting: Newsweek — https://newsweek.com/immigration-judges-first-amendment-appeal-supreme-court-12729314

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.