# Manager's 6-Minute Rejection Exposes HR Tech Flaw

> Manager rejected within 6 minutes for using 'React' instead of 'React.js' in application sparks debate over rigid HR tech screening.
- Title: Manager's 6-Minute Rejection Exposes HR Tech Flaw · mint
- Summary: Manager rejected within 6 minutes for using 'React' instead of 'React.js' in application sparks debate over rigid HR tech screening. A manager was rejected…
- Keywords: react, reactjs, hr tech, automated screening, job application, manager, recruitment system, news, india, Manager's, 6-Minute, Rejection
- Source: mint — https://livemint.com/news/trends/hiring-for-months-but-rejecting-qualified-candidates-manager-s-6-minute-rejection-raises-questions-about-hr-tech-11792678744578.html
- Author: Anjali Thakur
- Published: 2026-10-22T14:56:43+00:00
- Read time: 1 min
- Topics: react, reactjs, hr tech, automated screening, job application, manager, recruitment system, news, india
## Manager claims 6-minute rejection
A team lead said his company rejected qualified candidates within six minutes after applying under a different name.

> We have been rejecting every qualified applicant since april over punctuation, while i sat in weekly meetings being told the market was tough
## Vacancy open since April
The senior associate position remained unfilled for months despite weak candidate pipeline reports from HR.
## Application with different name
He submitted an application using a new email address and a different name to test the recruitment system.
## Rejection within 6 minutes
The application was rejected within six minutes due to a discrepancy between 'React' and 'React.js' in the CV.
## HR system keyword match
The screening process may have relied on an exact keyword match for 'React.js' while his CV listed 'React'.
## Concerns about screening criteria
Rigid screening criteria could prevent qualified candidates from reaching human reviewers.
## Key takeaway

A manager was rejected by his own company's HR system in 6 minutes after applying with 'React' instead of 'React.js', raising concerns about automated screening criteria.