# Martha Stewart beats Ina Garten in apple pie showdown

> A novice baker tested two iconic recipes and found only one actually tasted like apple pie.
- Title: Martha Stewart beats Ina Garten in apple pie showdown
- Summary: A novice baker tested two iconic recipes and found only one actually tasted like apple pie. A first-time baker compared Martha Stewart's Old-Fashioned Apple…
- Keywords: martha stewart, ina garten, apple pie, baking, recipe comparison, business, technology, Martha, Stewart, beats, Ina, Garten
- Source: Business Insider — https://businessinsider.com/apple-pie-recipe-comparison-martha-stewart-ina-garten
- Author: Gabbi Shaw
- Published: 2026-09-21T13:52:01.309+00:00
- Read time: 1 min
- Topics: martha stewart, ina garten, apple pie, baking, recipe comparison, business, technology
## A novice baker's fall challenge
As autumn approached, a first-time baker decided to make apple pie from scratch for the first time, choosing recipes from Martha Stewart and Ina Garten.
## Two recipes, two icons
The baker selected Martha Stewart's Old-Fashioned Apple Pie and Ina Garten's Deep-Dish Apple Pie, both from well-known cooking authorities.
## Making apple pie is hard
The baker's official review: making apple pie is not for the faint of heart, requiring specific kitchen gadgets and careful attention to detail.

> Making apple pie is not for the faint of heart.
## Only one tasted right
After baking both recipes, the baker found that only one of the two apple pies actually tasted like apple pie, comparing the results directly.
## Learn from the mistakes
The baker offers advice to anyone attempting these recipes: read the comparison, learn from the mistakes made, and ensure you have all required kitchen gadgets.
## Key takeaway

A first-time baker compared Martha Stewart's Old-Fashioned Apple Pie with Ina Garten's Deep-Dish Apple Pie and found only one delivered the expected flavour.