# Middle East Never New

> U.S. fantasies of a new Middle East keep failing despite military actions.
- Title: Middle East Never New · Foreign Policy | Shortify
- Summary: U.S. fantasies of a new Middle East keep failing despite military actions. The Middle East remains unchanged after U.S.
- Keywords: middle east, iran, u.s. military, strait of hormuz, houthi attacks, gulf states, iranian war, trump administration, saudi arabia, qatar, bahrain, imf projections
- URL: https://shortify.news/Foreign_Policy/middle-east-never-new
- Source: Foreign Policy — https://foreignpolicy.com/2026/11/10/middle-east-new-washington-arab-spring-iran-war
- Author: Steven Simon
- Published: 2026-11-17T00:00:00+00:00
- Read time: 3 min
- Topics: middle east, iran, u.s. military, strait of hormuz, houthi attacks, gulf states, iranian war, trump administration, saudi arabia, qatar, bahrain, imf projections
## U.S. Middle East Fantasies
Washington’s fantasies of transformation keep failing to pan out.
## 2003 Iraq Invasion
The 2003 invasion of Iraq was supposed to clear the way for a new, democratic Middle East.
## 2006 Lebanon War
The 2006 Lebanon War was, in U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice’s phrase, the 'birth pangs' of a new Middle East.
## Arab Spring 2009
The Arab Spring in 2009 was its dawn.
## Hamas Attack 2023
Hamas’s assault on Israel in 2023 was said to be ushering in a new Middle East.
## Trump's Transformation Claim
Per U.S. President Donald Trump, 'The Middle East will be transformed, and the future of that region has never, I don’t think it’s ever looked brighter.'
## Foreign Affairs Article
Foreign Affairs weighed in with an article titled 'The Iran Imperative: How America and Israel Can Shape a New Middle East.'
## Sam Rayburn's Analogy
As Sam Rayburn, House speaker in an earlier era observed: 'Any jackass can kick down a barn, but it takes a carpenter to build one.'
## U.S. Military Shortcomings
Decisive change for the better, in the United States’ conception, demands an actual preponderance of U.S. military power and the ability to convert that power into enduring political arrangements.
## Iran's Post-War Status
When the war ends, as it eventually will, Iran will still be a poor, militarized oil exporter with two good friends, China and Russia, and a strong relationship with Iraq.
## Iraq's Post-War Status
Iraq will look much as it does now, a state with a hybrid army trying to fend off pressure from Iran, with which it shares a long border, and from the United States, which controls…
## Syria's Post-War Status
Syria will look as it did the day before the United States and Israel struck Iran.
## Lebanon's Post-War Status
Lebanon will still be living with the results of the 1989 Taif Accord, which ended Lebanon’s civil war by rebalancing power among its sects and calling for every militia to disarm.
## Egypt's Post-War Status
Egypt, whose economy suffered badly when the Houthis were firing on ships in the Red Sea two years ago, will still be the same authoritarian state, propped up by Gulf largesse and embarked on gigantic…
## Jordan's Post-War Status
Jordan, necessarily careful given the mayhem on its Israeli, Syrian, and Iraqi borders, will look exactly as it did before the war.
## Gulf States Impact
Every Gulf state but Oman will see its economy shrink this year.The IMF projects contractions of 16.7 percent for Kuwait, 15.6 percent for Qatar, 11.
## Gulf Pipeline Projects
Most of these states are talking about huge new pipeline or transportation projects to make their export routes redundant and therefore more resilient to Iranian or Houthi attacks.
## Gulf States' Response
All will rush to rebuild their own air defenses now that the United States has shown itself to be relatively ineffectual as a wager of wars but still an eager arms dealer, source of intelligence…
## Trump's Ceasefire Plan
A concessionary cease-fire that restores normal traffic through the strait and frees the U.S. Navy to redeploy would not stop the war outright, since Trump would veto a war powers resolution.
## Gulf States' Hedging Strategy
The Gulf states would strike side deals with Iran to fully open the strait while holding onto as much U.S. intelligence, technology, weaponry, and expertise as they can.
## Key takeaway

The Middle East remains unchanged after U.S. military interventions, with no lasting transformation.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Foreign_Policy/middle-east-never-new
Reporting: Foreign Policy — https://foreignpolicy.com/2026/11/10/middle-east-new-washington-arab-spring-iran-war

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.