# Rahul Gandhi demands SIR debate with Modi

> Rahul Gandhi shares video urging Amit Shah to stop confusing PM Modi on SIR debate.
- Title: Rahul Gandhi demands SIR debate with Modi · Indiatimes
- Summary: Rahul Gandhi shares video urging Amit Shah to stop confusing PM Modi on SIR debate.
- Keywords: rahul gandhi, amit shah, modi, sir debate, parliament, voter rolls, special intensive revision, vote chori, lok sabha, prime minister, india, Indiatimes
- Source: Indiatimes — https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/convince-modi-ji-for-sir-debate-rahul-gandhi-tells-amit-shah-to-stop-confusing-pm-shares-video-of-remarks/articleshow/135611697.cms
- Author: Aastha Jha
- Published: 2026-11-06T15:13:00+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: rahul gandhi, amit shah, modi, sir debate, parliament, voter rolls, special intensive revision, vote chori, lok sabha, prime minister, india, news
## Rahul Gandhi's demand
Rahul Gandhi urged home minister Amit Shah to convince Prime Minister Narendra Modi to have an open debate on special intensive revision of voter rolls in Parliament.
## Shah's contradictory remarks
Amit Shah gave two different statements on SIR debate in Parliament, one on December 10, 2:025, and another on November 5, 2026.
## Shah's December 10, 2025 statement
Shah said discussion on SIR cannot take place inside Parliament as it falls under the Election Commission, an independent body.
## Shah's November 5, 2026 statement
Shah claimed the government was ready to call a special Parliament session to discuss SIR if Rahul Gandhi's concerns were valid.
## Shah's Karnal rally comment
Shah told Rahul Gandhi at a Karnal rally that he would not handle answers and would run away if he engaged in a responsible discussion.
## Rahul's call for debate
Rahul Gandhi claimed he could prove within five minutes that Modi was a 'deshdrohi' (traitor) in a SIR debate.
## Rahul's X post
Rahul Gandhi posted on X: 'Amit Shah ji, don't confuse Modi ji. Just convince him to have an open debate with me. Any platform, any time. Don't be afraid'.

> Amit Shah ji, don't confuse Modi ji. Just convince him to have an open debate with me. Any platform, any time. Don't be afraid
## SIR debate context
Special intensive revision (SIR) is a process to update voter rolls in Parliament, currently under debate between Rahul Gandhi and the government.
## Rahul's accusation
Rahul Gandhi accused the government of 'vote chori' (voter fraud) in Parliament.
## Shah's response
Shah responded to Rahul's accusation by saying the government was ready to discuss SIR if concerns were valid.
## Rahul's demand for action
Rahul Gandhi demanded immediate action to have a debate with Modi on SIR to prove he was a 'deshdrohi'.
## Shah's challenge
Shah challenged Rahul Gandhi to debate SIR in Parliament, saying he would not handle answers and would run away.
## SIR debate timeline
SIR debate timeline: December 10, 2025 (Shah on EC authority) and November 5, 2026 (Shah on government readiness).
## Rahul's video share
Rahul Gandhi shared a video of Shah's contradictory remarks on SIR debate in Parliament.
## Key takeaway

Rahul Gandhi told Amit Shah to convince Modi to have an open SIR debate, sharing video of Shah's contradictory remarks.