# Taxpayer wins Rs 3.98 crore tax case after ITAT quashes notices

> Gujarat taxpayer avoids Rs 4 crore tax additions after ITAT rules notices issued beyond legal deadline.
- Title: Taxpayer wins Rs 3.98 crore tax case after ITAT quashes…
- Summary: Gujarat taxpayer avoids Rs 4 crore tax additions after ITAT rules notices issued beyond legal deadline.
- Keywords: gujarat, shantilal ranchhodbhai dhanani, ahmedabad itat, tax additions, reassessment notices, section 69, section 148, section 148a, limitation period, tax department, income tax act, supreme court
- URL: https://shortify.news/Financialexpress/taxpayer-wins-rs-398-crore-tax-case-after-itat-quashes-notic
- Source: Financialexpress — https://financialexpress.com/money/rs-3-98-cr-tax-additions-i-t-department-misses-deadline-giving-taxpayer-a-big-win-4385532
- Author: Mithilesh Jha
- Published: 2026-11-16T04:25:36+00:00
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: gujarat, shantilal ranchhodbhai dhanani, ahmedabad itat, tax additions, reassessment notices, section 69, section 148, section 148a, limitation period, tax department, income tax act, supreme court
## Taxpayer wins Rs 3.98 crore tax case
Gujarat taxpayer Shantilal Ranchhodbhai Dhanani avoided nearly rs 4 crore in income tax additions after challenging reassessment notices issued beyond the permissible time limit.
## ITAT quashes tax notices
Ahmedabad ITAT ruled reassessment notices issued beyond the surviving limitation period were invalid for two assessment years.
## Tax additions challenged
Taxpayer faced rs 2.02 crore addition for 2015-16 and rs 1.96 crore addition for 2016-17 under section 69 of income tax act.
## Time limit dispute
Department issued notices on june 30 2021 but had only one day of limitation period before taxpayer response.
## Supreme Court ruling
Supreme Court held that time given to taxpayer to respond must be excluded from limitation period calculation.
## Taxpayer response deadline
Taxpayer submitted response on june 14 2022 giving department until june 21 2022 to complete reassessment.
## Department missed deadline
Department issued fresh notices on july 23 2022 and july 31 2022 after deadline expired.
## ITAT quashes notices
Ahmedabad ITAT set aside notices issued on july 23 and july 31 2022 for both assessment years.
## Gujarat High Court precedent
Gujarat High Court had previously ruled that notices beyond surviving limitation period are invalid.
## Taxpayer advice
Taxpayers should preserve original notices and supporting documents to challenge department procedures.
## What this means
Tax department must follow legal procedure and time limits when reopening assessments.
## Legal basis
Section 148 of income tax act allows department to reopen assessments with proper procedure.
## Taxpayer's legal argument
Taxpayer argued notices issued after limitation period expired and lacked proper cross-examination opportunity.
## Supreme Court interpretation
Supreme Court clarified that time for taxpayer response must be excluded from limitation period calculation.
## Taxpayer wins
Taxpayer avoided rs 3.98 crore tax additions by challenging notices issued beyond legal deadline.
## Key takeaway

Gujarat taxpayer Shantilal Ranchhodbhai Dhanani won Rs 3.98 crore in tax additions after Ahmedabad ITAT quashed reassessment notices issued beyond permissible time limits.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/Financialexpress/taxpayer-wins-rs-398-crore-tax-case-after-itat-quashes-notic
Reporting: Financialexpress — https://financialexpress.com/money/rs-3-98-cr-tax-additions-i-t-department-misses-deadline-giving-taxpayer-a-big-win-4385532

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.