# Trump Opposes Jack Smith's Deposition in Jan. 6 Defamation Lawsuit

> Trump calls Smith's testimony 'entirely irrelevant' as BBC warns of 'fundamental injustice' in defamation case.
- Title: Trump Opposes Jack Smith's Deposition in Jan. 6 Defamation…
- Summary: Trump calls Smith's testimony 'entirely irrelevant' as BBC warns of 'fundamental injustice' in defamation case. Trump claims Jack Smith has no relevant…
- Keywords: trump, jack smith, jan 6, defamation lawsuit, bbc, deposition, fundamental injustice, unrelevant testimony, crime, news, Opposes, Jack
- Source: Law & Crime — https://lawandcrime.com/high-profile/trump-opposes-jack-smiths-deposition-in-jan-6-defamation-lawsuit-as-entirely-irrelevant-while-bbc-sounds-alarm-about-fundamental-injustice
- Read time: 2 min
- Topics: trump, jack smith, jan 6, defamation lawsuit, bbc, deposition, fundamental injustice, unrelevant testimony, crime, news
## Trump's Lawsuit Against BBC
President Donald Trump filed a $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC over alleged false claims about his Jan. 6 speech.
## BBC Requests Deposition
The BBC urged the Southern District of Florida court to set a discovery hearing to force Trump to provide possible dates for a deposition.
## Trump's Unavailability
Trump's lawyers claim he will not be available for an Oct. 16 deposition due to a campaign rally in Dalton, Georgia, followed by a Mar-a-Lago fundraising event.
## Smith's Testimony
Former special counsel Jack Smith has only 'irrelevant' testimony to offer in the BBC matter, according to Trump's lawyers.
## BBC's Argument
The BBC says Trump's arguments for blocking Smith's deposition cannot withstand scrutiny and that Smith is the most authoritative source on the issues.
## Court Ruling
U.S. Magistrate Judge Enjoliqué Lett set a discovery hearing for 10 a.m. on Wednesday, warning of sanctions for continued lack of participation.
## Smith's Role
Smith prosecuted Trump in the Jan. 6 and Mar-a-Lago classified documents cases, which were both dismissed before and after Trump's 2024 election win.
## BBC's Concern
The BBC warns that Trump's refusal to depose Smith risks fundamental injustice by preventing the BBC from obtaining evidence to defend itself.
## Trump's Claim
Trump's lawyers claim the BBC's edit of his Jan. 6 speech in the Panorama documentary gave a 'mistaken impression' of violent action.
## Legal Basis
Trump's lawyers argue Smith lacks personal knowledge of Trump's speech or state of mind, making his testimony inadmissible.
## Historical Context
Trump's lawyers compared the current situation to his settled breach of contract lawsuit against his niece Mary Trump in New York.
## BBC's Stance
The BBC states that none of Trump's arguments for blocking Smith's deposition can withstand scrutiny and that Smith is the most authoritative source.
## Consequence
The BBC warns that Trump's refusal to depose Smith risks fundamental injustice by preventing the BBC from obtaining evidence to defend itself.
## Key takeaway

Trump claims Jack Smith has no relevant testimony for his Jan. 6 defamation lawsuit, while BBC says blocking deposition risks fundamental injustice.