# Trump's peace plan keeps failing Ukraine

> As the U.S. prepares fresh talks on ending the war, Trump's transactional approach clashes with Putin's geopolitical ambitions and Zelensky's survival.
- Title: Trump's peace plan keeps failing Ukraine · The New Yorker
- Summary: As the U.S. prepares fresh talks on ending the war, Trump's transactional approach clashes with Putin's geopolitical ambitions and Zelensky's survival.
- Keywords: donald trump, vladimir putin, volodymyr zelensky, russia ukraine war, peace negotiations, steve witkoff, jared kushner, starlink starshield, elon musk, sanctions, energy infrastructure, The New Yorker
- URL: https://shortify.news/The_New_Yorker/trumps-peace-plan-keeps-failing-ukraine
- Source: The New Yorker — https://newyorker.com/news/the-lede/why-russia-and-ukraine-keep-resisting-trumps-art-of-the-deal
- Author: Joshua Yaffa
- Published: 2026-11-09T11:00:00+00:00
- Read time: 3 min
- Topics: donald trump, vladimir putin, volodymyr zelensky, russia ukraine war, peace negotiations, steve witkoff, jared kushner, starlink starshield, elon musk, sanctions, energy infrastructure, politics
## Three-way talks resume in Abu Dhabi
On November tenth, the United States, Russia, and Ukraine will hold direct talks in Abu Dhabi after a nine-month break.U.S.
## Trump wants a quick win, not a real solution
Trump's approach to the war swings wildly but rests on one durable goal: end it fast to demonstrate his singular powers as a peacemaker and unlock a profitable relationship with Russia.
## Trump favors Russia because he thinks it will win
Trump believes Russia, with its larger economy, population, and army, is destined to prevail. He said last year, at some point, size will win. So he pressures the weaker party, Ukraine, toward settlement.

> At some point, size will win.
## Trump sees profit in Russia's resources
Trump views relations with Russia as offering more economic upside than relations with Ukraine, both for the U.S.and for his own family members and associates.He said in September it would be great for business.

> It'd be great for business. Russia's got great land, very valuable land.
## Witkoff and Kushner think Putin can be bought
Trump's envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner have projected transactional motives onto Putin, calling him a humanitarian and suggesting that economic incentives or territorial concessions can resolve the war.
## Putin is driven by historical grievance, not profit
Putin is guided by a sense of historical mission. He wants Western sanctions lifted and to capture the whole of the Donbas, but these are part of a larger ambition: righting geopolitical grievances the Kremlin…
## Putin wants control over Ukraine's future
Tatiana Stanovaya, a political analyst at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center, said Putin wants to determine Ukraine's geopolitical orientation and have a say over security in Europe, not merely economic gain.

> Putin wants to determine Ukraine's geopolitical orientation and have a say over security in Europe.
## Trump failed to bend Europe to his will
The Kremlin initially hoped Trump could deliver a grand geopolitical bargain by bending not just Kyiv's arm but Europe's too. But Trump proved incapable of meeting that expectation, Putin's foreign-policy adviser Yuri Ushakov noted.
## Trump's pressure backfired, Europe stepped in
Trump's attempts to pressure Volodymyr Zelensky, including an Oval Office blowup in February, led European countries to take the lead in backing Ukraine's defense.The E.U.committed ninety billion euros in loans while U.S.
## Trump offers Russia rewards before any deal
Trump began offering Moscow incentives not as rewards upon peace settlement but as benefits granted before one has been reached.
## The diesel deal was mostly messaging
The U.S.is a net exporter of diesel, and the amount Russia can credibly export will barely affect global prices.
## Trump secretly throttled Ukraine's drone speeds
For ten days in October, Ukraine faced sudden speed limitations when operating drones using Starshield, SpaceX's military application of Starlink.
## Ukraine got no explanation for the throttling
For days, neither Ukrainian military leaders nor top officials could get a direct answer about what happened or why.

> The worst thing was that there were absolutely no official explanations, nothing, zero.
## Zelensky refused to stop hitting Russian oil
On October thirtieth, Ukrainian strikes against Russian refineries resumed. Zelensky offered Trump a deal: if you want us to stop hitting Russian oil infrastructure, either reach a mutual agreement stopping Russian strikes on Ukrainian electricity…
## Zelensky openly breaks with Trump
Zelensky called Trump's diesel deal not fair and not honest and a birthday present for Putin.

> It's painful when President Trump chooses one side, not our side.
## All sides remain at odds over peace terms
Ukraine wants a ceasefire first, followed by negotiations over a larger settlement.Russia wants to silence the guns only once its fundamental demands have been met.Trump wants something fast that doesn't address the war's core causes.
## Ukraine faces a terrible winter ahead
On November second, Russian glide bombs struck a school in the Zaporizhzhia region distributing humanitarian aid, killing more than fifty people.This month saw Russia's largest attack of the year on Ukraine's energy infrastructure.
## Key takeaway

Trump's attempts to broker a quick peace deal between Russia and Ukraine through economic incentives have repeatedly failed because Putin seeks geopolitical control, not profit, while Ukraine refuses terms that leave it vulnerable.

---

Summary: Shortify — https://shortify.news/The_New_Yorker/trumps-peace-plan-keeps-failing-ukraine
Reporting: The New Yorker — https://newyorker.com/news/the-lede/why-russia-and-ukraine-keep-resisting-trumps-art-of-the-deal

When you use this summary, link the Shortify URL for the summary and credit the reporting to its newsroom.