From mint · Shipra Singh · · 2m
Arbitrage funds don't always win over liquid funds for short-term savings
Arbitrage funds face lower returns after STT hike, but tax benefits may still favor them for short-term savings.
In brief
Arbitrage funds face lower returns after STT hike, but tax benefits may still favor them for short-term savings. Arbitrage funds now match liquid funds' returns post-tax after STT increase, but tax advantages make them better for investors in higher tax brackets holding savings for months. Originally reported by mint.
Arbitrage funds and liquid funds
Arbitrage funds earn returns by pocketing price differences between cash market stocks and futures contracts.
Tax differences between funds
Arbitrage funds tax long-term gains at 12.5% versus liquid funds taxed at investor's income tax slab rate.
STT increase impacts returns
Higher securities transaction tax on futures reduced arbitrage funds' returns by 25 basis points annually.
Recent performance data
Both categories delivered average returns of 3.24% over six months, wiping out arbitrage funds' historical lead.
Tax advantages for higher brackets
For investors in 30% tax bracket, arbitrage funds offer 5.25% post-tax returns versus 4.2% for liquid funds.
Liquid funds' liquidity edge
Liquid funds have lower exit loads and instant redemption options compared to arbitrage funds.
Market volatility risks
Arbitrage funds can experience negative returns during market downturns like March 2020.
Tax rebate considerations
Investors with income up to ₹12 lakh may benefit from tax rebates on liquid fund gains.
When liquid funds are better
Liquid funds are better for short-term needs due to lower exit loads and stability.
When arbitrage funds are better
Arbitrage funds are better for long-term holdings beyond one year due to tax advantages.
Tax bracket considerations
Investors in 20% or lower tax brackets may find liquid funds more tax-efficient for short-term savings.
Key decision factors
Investors should consider duration, holding period, and tax slab rates when choosing between funds.
The main idea
Arbitrage funds now match liquid funds' returns post-tax after STT increase, but tax advantages make them better for investors in higher tax brackets holding savings for months.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.


