From the Guardian · · 1m 30s
Manchester United's Two Ronnies hiring dilemma
Manchester United's manager search mirrors a comedy sketch: picking past glories over current needs.
In brief
Manchester United's manager search mirrors a comedy sketch: picking past glories over current needs. Manchester United's board is rehiring a manager who may have been better suited to a past role, repeating a pattern of choosing historical success over present challenges. Originally reported by the Guardian.
Pochettino's career drift

Mauricio Pochettino's career shows signs of drift despite recent success with the USA men's team.
“M agnusson: And your time starts ... now! What is paleontology? Smithers: Yes, absolutely correct.”
Two Ronnies analogy

Manchester United's manager search mirrors a Two Ronnies comedy sketch where past answers are chosen over current questions.
“One of the Two Ronnies' most celebrated sketches involves a Mastermind contestant whose specialist subject is answering the previous question.”
Football's changing context

Football rarely stays still; what works now may not work in a season or two's time.
“The problem with football is that it never sits still. What was true once isn’t necessarily true now.”
Mourinho's United timeline

José Mourinho was considered for United in 2013 but turned down the job, later taking it in 2016.
“The possibility of José Mourinho becoming manager of United was first raised as Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013”
Mourinho's United challenges
Mourinho arrived at United in 2016 weary and fractious, with tactical doubts about modern players.
“José Mourinho seemed weary and fractious when the former Chelsea and Real Madrid manager arrived at Old Trafford in 2016”
Ten Hag and Amorim's failures
Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim were seen as rising stars but failed to adapt to United's needs.
“Ten Hag, skilfully as he managed Cristiano Ronaldo’s exit, seemed overawed by the job”
Pochettino's current status
Pochettino is 54 and has transformed Tottenham but faces questions about his long-term fit at United.
“He has done remarkable things: he may not yet have won trophies in England but he effected such an extraordinary transformation at Tottenham”
The hiring dilemma
Manchester United's board is repeating a pattern of choosing past glories over current needs for a manager.
“This feels like another appointment that would have been better made a few years ago”
Manager recruitment challenges
Only four managers have won the English league title with more than one club, highlighting recruitment difficulty.
“And that is very difficult, which is why only four managers have won the English league title with more than one club”
The Two Ronnies loop
Manchester United's manager search continues answering past questions rather than current ones.
“That United, once again, are answering the previous question”
The takeaway
Manchester United's board is rehiring a manager who may have been better suited to a past role, repeating a pattern of choosing historical success over present challenges.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.



