Cover art for NSW coalmine bill poses corruption risk, critics warn

NSW coalmine bill poses corruption risk, critics warn

Proposed legislation to expand Mount Pleasant mine contains a clause giving the resources minister sweeping powers to override state laws, raising serious concerns about concentrated authority.

Nov 16, 2026

11 cards · 3m · tap to begin

From · · 3m

NSW coalmine bill poses corruption risk, critics warn

Proposed legislation to expand Mount Pleasant mine contains a clause giving the resources minister sweeping powers to override state laws, raising serious concerns about concentrated authority.

In brief

Proposed legislation to expand Mount Pleasant mine contains a clause giving the resources minister sweeping powers to override state laws, raising serious concerns about concentrated authority. NSW parliament will debate a bill allowing MACH Energy to increase coal production at Mount Pleasant mine by thirty-two…

NSW to debate coalmine expansion bill

NSW to debate coalmine expansion bill

NSW parliament will this week debate legislation allowing MACH Energy to increase coal production at Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook by thirty-two percent to sixteen point five million tonnes per year.

Government says bill protects jobs

The Minns government announced the bill last month after the high court ruled an expansion of the mine was invalidly approved.

Clause gives minister sweeping powers

A clause in the bill would give the resources minister unusually broad powers to override other state laws.

Watson warns of corruption risk

Barrister Geoffrey Watson, director of the Centre for Public Integrity and former counsel assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption, says Clause seventeen creates a serious corruption risk by concentrating power in one person's hands…

“There are real problems with this as it is known that the concentration of this kind of power in the hands of one person creates a serious corruption risk.”

Corruption includes undue influence

Corruption includes undue influence

Watson told Guardian Australia that corruption in this context may not mean money passing hands. It also includes undue influence and decisions made in circumstances other than the public interest.

“corruption in that sense may not mean money passing hands. It also includes undue influence, decisions made in [circumstances] other than the public interest.”

Johnson raises similar legal concerns

Elaine Johnson, director of Johnson Legal representing Dams Heg in high court proceedings, raised similar concerns that Clause seventeen gave the resources minister unfettered power to make regulations changing the application of any state law…

Parliament to vote this week

The lower house is expected to debate the legislation on Tuesday, followed by the upper house later this week.

Coalition will not oppose the bill

Dave Layzell, Coalition resources spokesperson and Nationals MP for Upper Hunter, said the opposition would not oppose Labor's legislation in any way.

Greens seek to remove or limit clause

Greens climate spokesperson Sue Higginson said the Henry VIII clause was the broadest she had seen during the current parliament.

Greenwich calls clause dangerously broad

Greenwich calls clause dangerously broad

Independent MP Alex Greenwich, who intends to oppose the bill as a whole, said the provision was dangerously broad and quite unprecedented.

“It's especially concerning, given parliament won't sit for six months, meaning regulations issued during that time won't be able to be disallowed.”

Government defends transparency and process

Government defends transparency and process

A spokesperson for resources minister Courtney Houssos said the government had been clear the bill's purpose was to protect all permanent workers at Mount Pleasant.

The one thing

NSW parliament will debate a bill allowing MACH Energy to increase coal production at Mount Pleasant mine by thirty-two percent, but critics warn a clause giving the resources minister broad powers to override state laws creates serious corruption risks.

Read the original on the Guardian

Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.

More news from Australia

How we make summaries

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on mount pleasant mine and related topics.