From Eater · Eater Staff · · 1m
Eater Staff's Best Pie Recipes
Eater staff share their top pie recipes for holiday baking.
In brief
Eater staff share their top pie recipes for holiday baking. Eater staff recommend seven pie recipes including buttermilk pie, caramelized onion tart, and chocolate peanut butter pie. Originally reported by Eater.
Buttermilk Pie

Eater staff recommend buttermilk pie as a simple Southern dessert with nutmeg and lemon notes.
“The filling is smooth and velvety with subtle notes of nutmeg and a kiss of lemon”
Caramelized Onion & Butternut Squash Tart
This savory tart highlights fall flavors for Friendsgiving or Thanksgiving.
“It highlights flavors and ingredients of the season while standing out from pumpkin and pecan pies”
Chess Pie
A custard pie with evaporated milk and cornmeal, sometimes with lavender oil.
“It’s filled with evaporated milk and set perfectly with cornmeal”
No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
A simple five-ingredient pie using Cool Whip and peanut butter.
“It’s sweet, salty, creamy, and simultaneously light, fluffy, rich, and decadent”
Butterscotch Pie
A gooey butterscotch pie with a satisfyingly sticky consistency.
“It packs the same gooey, buttery taste and a satisfyingly sticky consistency”
Atlantic Beach Pie
A citrus pie with a salty, buttery saltine crust for holiday tables.
“It originated at a North Carolina seafood restaurant as a clever loophole to the old wives’ tale”
Chocolate Caramel Tart
A chocolate caramel tart with salt and creme fraiche for a sophisticated twist.
“It tastes like a slightly more sophisticated Twix Bar”
Sweet Potato-Miso Pie With Chocolate-Sesame Crust
A sweet potato-miso pie with a nutty chocolate-sesame crust for less-saccharine desserts.
“Most of the sweetness comes from the sweet potatoes themselves, complemented by brown sugar”
The bottom line
Eater staff recommend seven pie recipes including buttermilk pie, caramelized onion tart, and chocolate peanut butter pie.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.





