Judge's error overturned sentence

A legal error led to Max Factor heir Andrew Luster's 124-year prison sentence being thrown out and replaced with a 50-year term.

Original sentence details

Luster received 20 consecutive six-year terms for rape convictions, totaling 124 years, after being convicted in January 2003.

Resentencing process

Ventura County Superior Court Judge Kathryne Ann Stoltz granted Luster a new sentencing hearing in March 2013 after finding the original court failed to explain consecutive sentences.

Victim's letter request

One victim submitted a letter asking the judge to show leniency, stating, 'This is really gross what he did, but I think the guy's got some good character and you should be lenient on him.'

“This is really gross what he did, but I think the guy's got some good character and you should be lenient on him.”

Sentence reduction

The judge reduced Luster's sentence to 50 years by applying lighter terms to some rape counts, potentially saving 60 to 65 years in prison.

Parole release details

Luster was released to parole supervision on October 11, 2026, after completing his legally calculated prison term with 977 days of pre-sentence credit.

Prosecutors' stance

The Ventura County DA's office fought to preserve Luster's original 124-year sentence, stating drugging and raping women requires the strongest of sentences.

Parole restrictions

Luster must register as a sex offender for life, remain under parole supervision for three years, and avoid contact with victims.

Lawyer's defense

J. David Nick defended Luster's character, saying he never considered him dangerous despite his crimes.

Public reaction

Local leaders in Glendora, California, raised public safety concerns after Luster's release.