From The San Francisco Standard · · 2m
San Francisco Schools Turnaround
Two California superintendents advise patience for San Francisco's school reform.
In brief
Two California superintendents advise patience for San Francisco's school reform. San Francisco's superintendent Maria Su needs years to fix schools, following lessons from Garden Grove and Long Beach success stories. Originally reported by The San Francisco Standard.
Garden Grove's turnaround
Laura Schwalm led Garden Grove Unified School District to national acclaim after its test results were tied for dead last in Orange County.
“All I could say is, 'Well, we’re not technically last,' we’re tied.”
Long Beach's success
Chris Steinhauser led Long Beach Unified School District to win the Broad Prize for Urban Education before Schwalm's Garden Grove victory.
“We just had a lot of poverty.”
San Francisco's challenge
Superintendent Maria Su has led San Francisco's schools since October 2024, facing political instability and low student outcomes.
“This outcome is not a switch of a button or a flip of a switch. It will take years.”
Student demographics
San Francisco has 48,500 students with 54% low-income students, compared to 59% in Long Beach and 78% in Garden Grove.
“We just had a lot of poverty.”
Garden Grove's goals
Schwalm set a goal for every student to gain a year of learning for each year in the district, increasing UC/CSU eligibility from 19% to 55-60%.
“I called it being a benevolent dictator.”
Long Beach's approach
Steinhauser focused on small classes for low-income students, maintaining that wealthier parents understood their children's needs.
“Your kids are coming to the table with greater assets.”
San Francisco's math scores
25.3% of Long Beach Black students met math standards compared with 11.2% in San Francisco, with similar trends for Hispanic students.
“Black students in Long Beach met the math standard at 25.3%.”
Enrollment changes
San Francisco plans to replace its enrollment lottery with neighborhood schools starting in 2028-29, giving students options for citywide programs.
“It puts the responsibility squarely on the district to make sure that every single neighborhood school is worth choosing.”
Superintendent advice
Schwalm and Steinhauser advise San Francisco to focus on long-term gains over short-term wins and block out noise from political distractions.
“You can do anything, but not everything.”
Timeframe for change
Schwalm and Steinhauser say any district going through turnover will take five to 10 years to see meaningful improvements.
“Mile 17 is the mile that everybody cracks.”
Current progress
San Francisco has balanced its budget under Maria Su but seen little change in student outcomes since 2024.
“You can’t lie about your data.”
Next steps
Su hired John Davis, a deputy superintendent with 30 years in Baltimore and D.C. schools, to run SFUSD's academics.
“Any district that goes through this type of turnover is at least going to take five to 10 years.”
Long-term vision
Schwalm and Steinhauser believe San Francisco schools will improve if given time, with no quick fixes possible.
“They will if people will give [Su] the time.”
Final advice
Schwalm and Steinhauser urge San Francisco to keep going despite slow progress, saying 'don’t let it be the end'.
“Don’t let it be the end. Keep going.”
In short
San Francisco's superintendent Maria Su needs years to fix schools, following lessons from Garden Grove and Long Beach success stories.
Read the TL;DR — this story on one card.



