The best noise-canceling earbuds, tested on NYC subway platforms

One reviewer wore every top pair through traffic, gyms, and rush-hour crowds to find which ones actually block the world out.

By ·

Sep 14, 2026

20 cards · 4m · tap to begin

From · · · 4m

The best noise-canceling earbuds, tested on NYC subway platforms

One reviewer wore every top pair through traffic, gyms, and rush-hour crowds to find which ones actually block the world out.

In brief

One reviewer wore every top pair through traffic, gyms, and rush-hour crowds to find which ones actually block the world out. Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2nd Gen still has the strongest noise canceling, but the right pick depends on your phone, your gym bag, and your budget. Originally reported by WIRED.

Buy one pair, buy these

Noise-canceling earbuds cover calls, podcasts, workouts, commutes, and flights. If you only own one set of headphones, this is the category to spend on.

“If you buy only one pair of headphones, you should make it a good pair of noise-canceling earbuds.”

Good and great are far apart

Image may contain Electronics Appliance Blow Dryer Device Electrical Device and Headphones

Almost every wireless earbud claims noise cancellation now. Plenty of them do the job badly, which is why the gap between a decent pair and a great one is so wide.

“the difference between a good pair and a great pair is vast”

Tested against real chaos

No lab tone generators here. Every pick was worn on busy New York streets, loud cafes, crowded gyms, and rush-hour subway platforms.

Bose still holds the throne

The QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds (2nd Gen), $249 on sale, block more noise than anything else tested. Subway platform or international flight, the world mostly disappears.

“I've yet to find a pair of noise-canceling earbuds that can knock these off the throne”

What gen two fixed

Small upgrades that add up: stronger ANC, steadier Bluetooth, wireless charging, better personalized sound tuning, and more control inside the app.

The price of silence

These buds are big, expensive, and last only six hours with ANC on. Not the pair you grab for a run, but unbeatable when quiet is the whole point.

“But for ANC alone, it is the gold standard.”

Anker undercuts the field

The Soundcore Liberty 5 Pro delivers serious noise canceling for $150. Similar shape to the Bose, slightly smaller, with the same touch controls on each bud.

Best buds for calls

The Liberty 5 Pro beat every rival on noisy city streets for call quality. Add 6.5 hours of battery, a more secure fit, and an IP55 rating.

“these are some of the best earbuds for calls, full stop”

iPhone owners, stop here

AirPods Pro 3 swap between iPhone, MacBook, and Apple TV instantly, hook into Find My, and have a transparency mode that beats everyone else's.

“If you have an iPhone, you should probably just get the Apple AirPods Pro 3 earbuds.”

Your earbuds count heartbeats

Each AirPod Pro 3 has a heart rate sensor, so you can log a workout without a watch. Tested against Garmin and Google wearables, the numbers held up.

Samsung's answer

Galaxy Buds4 Pro copy the AirPods playbook with pinch-and-slide stems, GPS tracking, and instant device swapping. A dual-speaker setup gives them richer bass.

“I wouldn't recommend the Galaxy Buds for anyone outside of Samsung's ecosystem, though.”

Pixel Buds go small

Pixel Buds Pro 2 cancel less than Bose or Apple but weigh far less. Mini wingtips lock them in better than AirPods, and IP54 plus long battery covers everything.

Sony wins on sound

The WF-1000XM6 pairs near-Bose noise canceling with memory foam tips that seal out sound passively. Dial in the fit and the surroundings vanish.

“perhaps the best-sounding wireless earbuds that I've tested”

The fit is the catch

Getting the Sony seal right took several ear tip swaps before they felt comfortable. That fussiness is the only reason Bose keeps the ANC crown.

Powerbeats survive the gym

Powerbeats Pro 2 finally add strong ANC to a sport design. Wraparound hooks hold through anything, and physical buttons work with gloves on.

“I've literally smacked my ears around with my hands just to see if they would budge”

Thirty dollars, real basics

JLab Go Pop ANC has so-so noise canceling but stable Bluetooth, adjustable EQ, programmable controls, IP55, and six hours of playback.

“They nail the basics, and for $30, that's a win all on its own.”

How the magic works

Two things happen at once. The earbud physically plugs your ear, then microphones listen to incoming sound waves and generate the exact opposite waveform to cancel them.

Why it never gets to zero

Your environment throws many sounds at once, some steady like an AC hum, some sudden like a voice. Software cannot erase all of it.

“ANC can't cancel every sound in your environment, but the best headphones get impressively close.”

Transparency mode and wind

Transparency pipes the world back in, and Apple does it best. Try it on an ebike, though, and wind ruins the effect. Open earbuds suit outdoor sport better.

“it mostly sounds like a blistering blast of artificial wind noise”

Weeks, not minutes

Each pair gets worn for weeks across calls, music, TV, and flights, with audio sampled across genres on Spotify Lossless rather than one fixed playlist.

“I test all kinds of headphones, including noise-canceling ones, the way regular people might use them.”

The bottom line

Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2nd Gen still has the strongest noise canceling, but the right pick depends on your phone, your gym bag, and your budget.

Read the original on WIRED

React

Sign in to react and comment.

Comments (0)

Life is short. Keep it sweet. Respect others' opinions and be kind!

    Recommended next

    More decks on earbuds and related topics.