Google won't let schools have search without AI

Google's new AI policy for schools

Google announced a new approach to AI in K-12 schools this week, saying it would give schools more control. Early reports suggested Google would block search access for schools rejecting AI.

Schools must opt into AI products

Schools using Google apps must opt into AI products going forward. Google considers search part of its AI portfolio alongside Gemini, Gemini Notebook, and Gemini in Classroom.

The New York Times interpretation

Google's VP for education spoke exclusively to The New York Times, which interpreted the situation as Google will turn off search if schools reject AI. This framing suggested a punitive approach.

Google clarifies the actual options

Google clarified that schools can disable Gemini apps while leaving search active. Schools wanting to block all AI can remove search from student accounts entirely.

Search now includes AI by default

Currently schools can block Gemini but AI tools in search like AI Overviews and AI Mode remain active. Under the new system, schools choosing search must also choose AI features.

Google refuses AI-free search

Google's new approach does not include the ability to use search without AI. The company sees AI as the future of search and steadfastly refuses to create a toggle to disable it.

“Google steadfastly refuses to create such a toggle”

Alternatives may improve soon

Switching to another search provider is difficult because Google has the most expansive index. However, Google's loss in the DOJ's search antitrust case will require it to provide competitors limited access to its index.