From SI · · 1m 50s
Why Starting J.J. McCarthy Is Right for Giants, But Not
Giants start J.J. McCarthy over Winston but face tough Texans test.
In brief
Giants start J.J. McCarthy over Winston but face tough Texans test. Giants will start J.J. McCarthy against Texans after Winston's benching, but his first start may be risky against a strong Houston team. Originally reported by SI.
Quick answers
- Why start McCarthy?
- McCarthy's mobility gives coordinator Matt Nagy more run game opportunities and chemistry with Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely.
- What is the key takeaway from Why Starting J.J. McCarthy Is Right for Giants, But Not?
- Giants will start J.J. McCarthy against Texans after Winston's benching, but his first start may be risky against a strong Houston team.
Giants shake up QB plans
Giants start J.J. McCarthy at quarterback after Jameis Winston was benched in Sunday's loss to Saints.
McCarthy's debut performance
McCarthy led Giants on three scoring drives in final frame after throwing interception on first possession.
McCarthy's stats
McCarthy finished 11-for-21 for 243 yards, one touchdown, an interception, and a passer rating of 90.0.
McCarthy's background
McCarthy, 23, was selected by Vikings with No. 10 pick in 2024 NFL draft but traded to Giants in late September.
Why start McCarthy?
McCarthy's mobility gives coordinator Matt Nagy more run game opportunities and chemistry with Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely.
Trade deal details
Giants sent 2027 fifth-round pick to Vikings for McCarthy with another year on rookie contract.
McCarthy's role
McCarthy has learned Nagy's system in less than a month but only in backup role with minimal first-team reps.
Coach Callahan's view
Quarterbacks coach Brian Callahan feels McCarthy can operate a game plan but may need time to adjust.
Harbaugh's confidence
Coach Harbaugh says McCarthy has the game plan down and will be ready for Week 7.
Texans' strength
Texans have won two consecutive games after opening season 0, 4 and are strong Super Bowl contenders.
Cam Ward's performance
Cam Ward threw for 170 yards and an interception against Texans while Titans scored only three points.
Week 7 challenge
Giants face Texans in Week 7 on road with McCarthy making first start against strong defense.
Harbaugh's decision
Harbaugh willing to take risk of starting McCarthy against Texans despite potential challenges.
The one thing
Giants will start J.J. McCarthy against Texans after Winston's benching, but his first start may be risky against a strong Houston team.
